Published: 1 November 2016
Last updated: 4 March 2024
Survivor Manny Waks describes his many achievements to date in this memoir written with Michael Visontay.
Born in 1976, Waks, the second of 17 children, was raised in Melbourne’s Chabad community, an ultra-Orthodox sect of Judaism that ruled his life. He lived across the road from the Yeshivah Centre, which includes the Yeshivah College. At home, discipline was extremely harsh.
All problems, major and minor, were brought to the rabbi, who dictated solutions. Absolute obedience was demanded of both children and adults and the weapons of choice in enforcing it, as evidenced by the treatment later meted out to Waks and other victims of child sexual abuse and their families, were shame, ridicule, ostracism, nasty gossip and outright slander.
Life in the Chabad community, in which all obeyed the rules without question and were infantilised to the point that they were often unable to independently weigh decisions or make moral judgments according to conscience, induced a hierarchy of powerlessness that often found expression in the abuse of what power one had. Children in such situations are most vulnerable; too often easy victims.
As a young child, Manny Waks was impervious to the hypocrisy inherent in his Chabad community and its disempowering effects but life changed dramatically for him when at the age of 11, he became a victim of child sexual abuse, an ordeal lasting three years. The two abusers came from within the Yeshiva of the Chabad community. Like all child victims, Waks did not understand that he had been groomed, and no adult noticed his distress.
To Waks, the sexual abuse was a “betrayal of everything I knew” He confided in a classmate who betrayed the confidence. Soon the abuse was being openly spoken about by students, teachers and other adults and Waks found himself being bullied and abused by other children. Adults could not have failed to be aware but offered neither support nor intervention.
When Waks became the victim of the second predator, he confided in no one, but nevertheless it soon became common knowledge in the Yeshivah, and the bullying intensified. In a typical victim response he blamed himself, consciously or unconsciously. He felt shame, embarrassment and humiliation, and began to "act out", performing badly at school and becoming disruptive. He was moved from formal education to full time religious studies but was soon ignoring many religious practices and consuming large amounts of alcohol. His “cry for help” was met with exclusion from class by teachers and physical beatings by his father. Waks states that he was not prepared to handle the sexual abuse, perhaps missing the point that it was not his responsibility but that of those to whom his care was entrusted, to protect him from predators and, should this fail, to nurture and set him on the path of healing.
Despite their absolute authority, the rabbis and leaders of the Chabad community displayed an extreme lack of understanding of the predatory nature and criminal activities of paedophiles. Their blind ignorance further emboldened the children. Waks was informed by peers that “everyone” should have known that the second abuser was, [rightly or wrongly] homosexual and therefore Waks must also be homosexual and have invited the crimes. As victim he was both blamed and punished.
It is most disturbing that such gross distortions of fact and reality, including the conflation of homosexuality and paedophilia, could be espoused by rabbis responsible for Chabad children. Also ignored was the imbalance of power between victim and perpetrator and the fact that a child cannot give consent.
At 17, educationally disadvantaged and still nursing open wounds, Waks left school and decided to make aliyah, leaving Melbourne shortly after his 18th birthday to enrol in the Israeli Defence Force (IDF). After a series of adventures and misadventures, he returned home to Australia in 2000.
In 1996, while home on leave from the IDF, Waks was prompted to speak to Victoria Police about his sexual abuse but no action was taken. At this time he also told a rabbi, the Yeshivah Centre director, but four years later the abuser continued to have full access to children. He spoke again to the rabbi, who dismissed his concerns.
After returning home to live, Waks married, found employment, commenced study, and eventually graduated with a degree in International Relations.
In 2011 Waks had an article published in Melbourne's The Age newspaper in which he spoke of his sexual abuse and its detrimental consequences to him and his family.
By going public about his abuse, Waks broke the rules against mesirah (informing), considered by many a crime “worse than the original offence, worse than molesting a young boy”.
In 2012 Waks gave evidence before the Victorian Parliamentary Committee. Following this, his extensive victim advocacy inspired him to establish Tzedek, a support and advocacy group for Jewish victims and survivors of child sexual abuse, an organisation in which he held various positions.
Waks considers that his appearance before the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse was both vindication and achievement for him. He was granted a public hearing and became the public face of the campaign in the Australian Jewish community, the first time it had come under such intense scrutiny and a first for Jewish communities worldwide. Jewish religious and community organisations and their leaders were conspicuous by their absence.
For daring to publicly defend the rights of Jewish victims, Waks met with more hostility. Meanwhile, known abusers within the community had been left in positions in which they were able to continue abusing children. This was in marked contrast to the cold-shoulders or overt hostility and abuse often meted out to victims. Their abuse was further enabled by the silence of Yeshivah leaders.
“When I challenged the leaders - religious, secular and communal - to acknowledge the scale of the problem, address it and ensure that others didn't have to experience what I did, their response was first to ignore me, then to downplay it and then to say it was being addressed. When I demonstrated that they were wrong on all counts, they shunned me. They ostracised me and my family, casting me and my parents out of the only community and life that we had known.”
Such intolerance of dissent suggests a closed-mindedness that allows nobody to grow and flourish.
Attacks on Waks by Jewish community leadership have included the discrediting of his and other victims’ evidence, and choosing to ignore the substance of his campaign, that is, to stop the abuse of children, to obtain a measure of justice for the victims, to reduce the likelihood of such crimes being committed in the future and, should they occur, to mitigate their impact. This is surely the right of every child and also of any parent who entrusts children to care, guidance and education in Jewish communities from ultra-Orthodox to Liberal, not to mention the Catholic and other institutions which have so grievously failed their sexual abuse victims to date.
Unbowed, Waks continues his work, in 2016 launching Kol v’Oz, an international organisation of which he is the founding CEO. It aims to become the leading voice on child sexual abuse in the Jewish world.
This is a forthright and compelling narrative, its "warts-and-all" self-reflective approach written with an informality of style that will readily hold the attention of readers. ‘Who gave you permission?’ is particularly recommended for parents, teachers, all those to whom the care of children is entrusted and for all people committed to ending the societal scourge of child sexual abuse. As the writers intended, it will also give strength and hope to victims and survivors.
Here is one place to purchase the book.
This The Jewish Independent article may be republished if acknowledged thus: ‘Reprinted with permission from www.thejewishindependent.com.au ’
Comments
No comments on this article yet. Be the first to add your thoughts.