Published: 30 May 2018
Last updated: 4 March 2024
We chose to spend four and half months in Brooklyn, New York. We also travelled occasionally to other major centres of Jewish life (Seattle, Chicago, Boston). Aside from some practical reasons regarding housing options, we were advised that it would be interesting to spend this time in Brooklyn rather than in the all-so-familiar Manhattan.
Brooklyn was once considered the second stage of (Jewish) immigration to America. When immigrants graduated from the “hellish” initial experience of immigration, found work, learned the language and brought the rest of the family from the “old country”– they would typically move to Brooklyn (or the Bronx, Queens, or Newark in New Jersey, etc.).
In those neighbourhoods they were able to create a respectful life, next to fellow Jewish immigrants in the context of the emerging American middle class. Many prominent American Jews, such as the recently deceased author Philip Roth, grew up in similar circumstances. Their Jewish identity was constructed in those very Jewish urban environments.
And then came the third stage. In the post-World War II era Jews did so well in places like Brooklyn that they jumped at the opportunity that arose in the 1940s, '50s and '60s and moved to the suburbs. This trend happened in most major urban centres of the United States. Jewish life changed dramatically. After being concentrated in urban locales, where the term a ‘Jewish area’ or neighbourhood was very concrete, Jews moved away to large open sub-urban spaces farther from the urban landscape.
Jewish life had to be reconfigured. Now Jews did not live next to other Jews, they were far away from synagogues and other Jewish spots, and even far away from one another. This was the hey day for Conservative and Reform Judaism, the two American non-Orthodox religious movements that adapted to the new social order and provided religious and communal services that answered the needs of the new realities.
[gallery columns="2" size="medium" ids="20185,20186"]
But this stage is also now coming to a crossroad. The successful third and fourth generation Jews, those who grew up in the suburbs, went off to college. There and afterwards they did very well in academia, business and other professions. And they did not return to their parents’ suburban environments.
This new generation also enjoyed the fall of (most) barriers between Jews and non-Jews, resulting in many intermarriages and decline in Jewish expressions as well as full integration into American culture. To date, the gigantic suburban synagogues are suffering from decline in attendance and severe financial challenges.
This brings us back to Brooklyn. New York is going through a dramatic urban renaissance, as are other major cities in the US such as Chicago, San Francisco, Atlanta and Boston. Young people are flocking back to the cities, looking for the urban experience. They are willing to pay a lot of money and other resources to live closer to the “action”. “
Brooklyn, the gigantic borough still with 2.6 million residents, is a hotspot of this process. One neighbourhood after the other is going through renewal, facelift, housing gentrification, becoming young and “cool”.
This is essentially good for Jewish life. Jewish millennials and young families in the thousands are filling the streets, cafes, schools and parks of Brooklyn. It is a great opportunity for the rejuvenation of Jewish life. The assumption is that among those new urbanites there are many who seek community and are interested in a rich Jewish expression for themselves and their children. The problem is that they are not eagerly running to the dusty dark synagogues that were left there from previous generations.
In the course of our stay we have witnessed multiple creative attempts to renew Jewish life: platforms for communal Shabbat meals, new social networks, study groups, family programming, outdoor activities and social action initiatives are all popping up.
In order to ensure that this will be a real Jewish renaissance, the establishment needs to think outside the box and invent new models of recruitment and attracting membership, as well as coming up with creative measures to retain participants in programs over time.
My prediction is that the next source of renewal of Jewish life will occur in major urban centres such as New York, London, Tel Aviv, Berlin and Sydney. The example of Brooklyn can highlight how to glean the opportunities and obstacles for the next generation.
Main photo: East Midwood Jewish Centre
Other photos: Elan Ezrachi


