Published: 8 May 2025
Last updated: 7 May 2025
For some, Jews would be wise to keep a bag packed just in case, and for some with that belief, this might be the time to check your passport too.
These folk warn that we’ve been living in a fool’s paradise post-Holocaust and that antisemitism, apparently dormant, would rise again. The normal condition of the Jewish people would reassert itself and, once again, being Jewish will be full of travail. Only the Holocaust inhibited reasonably decent people from expressing what lay just beneath the surface— the normative reality that most people didn’t like most Jews.
I must admit that hasn’t been my experience. I’ve found, on the contrary, that most people are intrigued by and admiring of Jews. True, one could often detect envy in their admiration but that’s because being Jewish, not only in the modern world but often through history, has been so enviable!
A provincial perspective
I live in a small Jewish community in the west of England (in Bristol) and the last 18 months have not produced a vast outpouring of animosity on our streets. In fact, just recently, a Jewish community grandee came to visit our community to speak and started his speech with something like, “of course, this last 18 months have been really challenging for us all but I want to accentuate the many positive factors that still exist”. I looked round the room and could see most people thinking “why does he say it’s been challenging?”
Comments2
Harold Zwier11 May at 08:12 am
I am aware that not all people will see their sense of belonging in Australia reflected in Clive Lawton’s words, but his words certainly speak to me. One can argue about the responsiveness and effectiveness of governments in addressing antisemitism, but it’s an issue of degree. Simply stated, I don’t feel uncomfortable or anxious living in Australia.
Miriam Frommer9 May at 08:18 am
It is really heartening to read that there are many places where antisemitism and anti-Zionism have not reared their ugly heads, and that the Jews living there feel secure. Hopefully Clive Lawton’s observations will help restore some balance to the catastrophising which has characterised the discourse in some communities.