Aa
  • Read, Watch, Listen
  • TJI Series
  • Community Action
  • Events
  • Zedi
Follow us and continue the conversation
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Test yourself with the TJI Quiz!

Adjust size of text

Aa

Follow us and continue the conversation

  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube

Your saved articles

You haven't saved any articles

What are you looking for?

Original reporting, insightful analysis and diverse views, delivered straight to your inbox

  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Your support fuels our mission to inform, entertain and inspire.

The Jewish Independent is bound by the Standards of Practice of the Australian Press Council. If you believe the Standards may have been breached, you may approach The Jewish Independent or make a complaint to the Australian Press Council in writing at www.presscouncil.org.au. The Council may also be contacted on 1800 025 712.

  • Our Story
  • Contact us
  • Our Team
  • Support us
  • Guidelines
  • Pitch your idea
  • Republishing us
  • Community Action
  • Our Awards
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Aboriginal FlagTorres Strait Islanders Flag

The Jewish Independent acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the Traditional Owners and Custodians of Country throughout Australia. We pay our respects to Elders past and present, and strive to honour their rich history of storytelling in our work and mission.

© The Jewish Independent 2026All Rights Reserved
Website design and development by Your Creative, MelbourneTerms & ConditionsPrivacy Policy
HomeRead, Watch, ListenAustralia
Australia Votes 2025OpinionAustralia

We must vote on whole platforms as Australians, not just as Jews

Our votes must not be driven solely by antisemitism or Israel, and we must not be tempted by right-wing rhetoric that seeks to divide Australians.
Isabelle Oderberg
Print this
election ballot vote

Illustration: TJI

Published: 28 March 2025

Last updated: 28 March 2025

When a leaked video showed NSW Greens MP Jenny Leong describing how the “Jewish and Israel lobby” reach their tentacles into social justice campaigns, such as the fight to stop the watering down of racial vilification laws (known as 18C), because they want to “influence power”, I was angry for innumerable reasons. 

I have volunteered and worked professionally in social justice and for-purpose sectors for much of my life. I was also raised by two Orthodox (in principle if not practice) parents in a thoroughly Jewish home. Tikkun olam and tzedakah were always at the heart of every single lesson of what it meant to be a Jew. 

This is evident in the Australian philanthropic landscape, where Jewish donors punch well above their weight in terms of charitable giving across a number of causes, frequently outside their own community. 

Every single Jewish community with which I’ve been involved, both in Australia and overseas, has run social justice activities both within and outside their own gates, from large-scale campaigns and interfaith initiatives, to charity outreach programs, like soup kitchens, children’s giving programs, kitchen pantries and so on.  

As a mother to Aboriginal children, I am proud of the work Jewish community groups have done working to support the civil rights of First Nations People on stolen land. This stretched back to grassroots community groups who worked to bring about change during the lead-up to the 1967 referendum, the Jewish lawyers who worked on Eddie Mabo’s Native Title case, and through to almost all Jewish community groups vocally and actively supporting the Yes vote in last year’s Voice to Parliament referendum. 

We’ve watched in horror as President Donald Trump has moved to enact a raft of frightening policies that seek to curtail the rights of many disenfranchised groups (diversity initiatives, LGBTQI+ rights and women’s reproductive freedom to name a few).

I am not going to tell anyone how to vote. But I am going to beg Australian Jews, and all voters, to vote for a body of work.

Despite presenting himself as the only way forward for Israel, Trump has long courted the company of neo-Nazi extremist groups, as has his offsider Elon Musk. Anyone who was surprised by Musk’s address to Germany’s far right anti-immigrant party Alternative for Germany, during which he said Germans should “move past the guilt of the Holocaust”, simply wasn’t listening or paying attention. 

As human beings, what we see and hear is selective. Worldwide Jewry is scared. Of course we are. A surge in anti-Jewish hate tends to have that effect. But here is what gives me hope. 

Traditionally and historically, around 20-30 per cent of American Jews vote Republican. During the most recent US election, just 21 per cent of American Jews voted Republican. A huge 71 per cent of Jews, despite their fear, still voted for an alternative to Trumpism, because they were able to see past the politics.

Australians will go to the polls this year. Already we can see parties positioning themselves for an election; funding announcements, grandstanding, playing for every single political point, because, of course, that’s what politicians do.

I am not a member of any party. I assess the candidates each election and vote based on who I think is either the candidate who reflects my values, will best represent my electorate and who I think will be a needed voice in whichever party room they sit, or in the case of independents, in whichever house they sit. 

October 7 and all that has happened since have shaped our lives. But there are issues around us that extend beyond this one.

I am not going to tell anyone how to vote. Or which party deserves your support. I am, however, going to beg Australian Jews, and indeed all Australian voters, to vote for a body of work. To look beyond political point-scoring and words that bely the historical record and tell you what you want to hear.

A candidate or party that makes the most promises based on the issues of the day, the one who lulls you into a sense of security on which they simply cannot deliver, is not going to be your best representative in our democratic system.

The events of October 7 and all that has happened since have no doubt shaped our lives, in some ways harming us irreparably. But there are issues all around us that extend beyond this one. We are Jews, but we are also Australians. The healthcare system is not fit for purpose and women’s health has been shamefully underfunded and understudied.

Our public schools are in desperate need of attention and priority. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples are still being incarcerated at record rates and dying a decade younger than non-Aboriginal people. Climate change continues apace.

We can also never forget that we came to this country as migrants. While Jewish convicts were present in the First Fleet, the majority of our community in Australia is made up of people who migrated here or came here seeking safety in the past 70 years. It is our moral obligation not to pull up the gang plank behind us. 

Lurching towards right-wing, Trumpist-style politics that seeks to divide, rather than unite and stoke our fears, rather than work to deliver real solutions to the problems we face, would be a grave error in judgment and one we will come to regret.

Most of us came here as migrants. It is our moral obligation not to pull up the gang plank behind us.

According to the director of pollster RedBridge Group Australia, Kos Samaras, polling already shows the Australian conservative vote is consolidating. When I asked him if every vote is going to be important this election, he gave me an emphatic “yes”. Samaras says the federal election will be one of the closest we’ve seen and emphasises that it’s essential people understand what they’re voting for and how Australia’s murky preference system works.  

I don’t want an Australia with curtailed abortion and reproductive rights, as was almost legislated in South Australia just months ago. I don’t want my community’s pain to be weaponised for political gain. I don’t want people policed for how they identify their gender. I want my children to one day own a home or be able to afford to pay rent. I do not want the laws that protect us against hate speech watered down to allow for “debate” over one human being’s worth or value over another. 

Aussies love sport, right? So let me say this: remember to look at the ladder for the whole season; not just the match-up of the loudest teams or indeed players. 

Our role in democracy, as a community and as individuals, cannot be based on one issue. It has to be based on all the aspirations we have for our society, equality and, most importantly, repairing the world, or, in the more traditional meaning of tikkun olam, maintaining social order. 

You might also like
  • The Altalena should be a warning, not a political weapon
    Shahar Burla
  • Turkey emerges as military threat to Israel
    Dror Doron
  • Because of my Zionist values, I’m joining an Arab party
    Yoav Segalovitz
logomark.67a07ee3
We believe in the free flow of information

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, by using our Creative Commons licence

You might also like

    Generation Change: Rachel Moshel
    Generation ChangeInterviewArts & Culture

    Rachel Moshel: Creating a space for Jewish art and joy

    Gideon Cohen
    ANNIKA WELLS PRESSER
    Israel Hamas WarNewsAustralia

    No action to stop Hezbollah ally beaming antisemitic and anti-Israel content into Australia

    Michael Visontay
    Beinart Doogue 600
    Israel Hamas WarNewsAustralia

    Beinart takes a wrecking ball to Israel

    Michael Visontay 1

About the author

Isabelle Oderberg

Isabelle Oderberg

Isabelle Oderberg's journalism has appeared in The Age/SMH, Guardian, ABC, Meanjin and elsewhere. She also worked as a media and communications strategist across the not-for-profit sector. She is the author of Hard to Bear: Investigating the science and silence of miscarriage (Ultimo Press), and Chair of the Early Pregnancy Loss Coalition. Learn more at eplc.au.

More from the author

OpinionAustralia

The new McCarthyism: Anti-Zionist witch hunts

OpinionAustralia

‘Australian values’ – an immigration test with no answer

OpinionArts & Culture

Randa Abdel-Fattah is a perverse poster child for free speech

OpinionArts & Culture

I would have attended Bendigo Writers Festival… and said anything I liked

Comments9

  • Avatar of Jim James

    Jim James6 March at 10:33 am

    Everything Oderberg has said here is wrong. Every prediction way off, in hindsight it was not a close federal election, Albanese showed his true colours after Bondi massacre and Trump and Nattanyahu are currently kicking Irans butt. Just because the author has been a journo for over 20 years doesn’t mean she has learnt anything. Just another confused lefty that thinks appeasement is the solution to everything, time to wake T F up. How the Jews keep voting for labor is beyond me. Labor hates the Jews.

  • Avatar of Marcos

    Marcos24 April at 10:38 pm

    This extremist hates Trump and Musk, and overlooks the damage Biden has done to Israel and the civilized world. As soon as I read “Trump” I stopped reading.

  • Avatar of Naomi McKeown

    Naomi McKeown2 April at 04:26 am

    To all: Greens does not equal ‘teal’. (“Green/teal” is misleading and veering towards misinformation.) I know it has more syllables, but rather than ‘teal’, the appropriate term is Community Independents. While some do side more with the left (and are more Green-aligned), some are further to the (centre) right. It depends on where you live.

  • Avatar of David Jackson

    David Jackson29 March at 02:20 am

    I know from personal experience Jews will vote on local economic, such as cost of living issues first and foremost, which Partys’ policies are best for me and my family. This is not a homogenious vote. All other issues are secondary.

  • Avatar of Ian Grinblat

    Ian Grinblat28 March at 06:35 am

    Isabelle,
    I fail to understand why you confuseAustralian and US politics, especially on abortion rights. You are quite right that we should be weighing performance over the full term of government and on policy direction. However, I remain utterly unimpressed by the performance of the Albanese government and have no faith in any of its members to engage deeply with any issue at all. Social Cohesion has become serious challenge and the government’s response was to impose a troika but not even harnessed to the same vehicle: a Jewish woman as envoy on the “Jewish” concern about antisemitism, a Muslim man as the envoy on the Muslim concern of Islamophobia, and a third man as the envoy on social cohesion. Are not antisemitismm and Islamophobia the current main challenges to social cohesion?
    What respect has the PM even shown for his own Attorney-General if he allowed him to be sent to Israel to “clean” the mess quite deliberately made by our Foreign Minister – I suspect that the attitude was, “Well, Dreyfus is a Jew, so he’ll know how to talk to ‘them’.”
    Err, no thanks.

  • Avatar of Rachel Sussman

    Rachel Sussman28 March at 04:39 am

    Thankfully we still live in a democracy where we are each entitled to our opinion and choice.
    It is a strange thing that whilst the author keeps telling us that ‘I do not want to tell you how to vote’ she does a good clear job in doing just this…
    I respect your view but please respect mine.
    Personally, I am sick and tired of some telling me over and over how bad Trump is, how bad Elon Musk is, how horrible the Right is… Trump, Musk and if you pardon me Biden and Harris all have their faults and one may or may not agree with their stance and this is perfectly ok… Saying this, It seems that for some, the Right is equated with the far right and the Left is pardoned from its dangerous far Left rhetoric that sadly is dominating it today… As for me, the Left I once loved has long died and has been replaced with an intolerable doctrine that only accepts itself and has no respect for others which in a weird way is everything the Left claims not to be… Yes there are some far Right that one must be weary of and are as dangerous as the far Left, but strangely today these are at the fringes of the Right, while the far Left has somehow become the norm…
    The Labor Government under Albanese has caused much damage not only economically and in terms of world-relation, but in terms of dividing Australian society in an unforgivable way…
    As for me, I will follow my heart. Yes, I will not betray myself as an Australian Jew allowing Australia betrayed me; yes I will not betray Israel for it is my anchor; and yes I will not betray the Australia I once loved…
    Each of us must listen to their heart and vote in accordance to its whisper and let us pray that whatever the outcome, it is the best for Australia, for us Australian Jews, for Israel and for the world…

  • Avatar of chris Fitzpatrick

    chris Fitzpatrick28 March at 03:47 am

    Congratulations Linda. Your broad minded thinking shows your humanitarianism. I’m afraid of Dutton’s (& Trumps) attitude to think & behave inwardly & selfishly, and appears to be based on racism, sexism & bigotry.

  • Avatar of chris Fitzpatrick

    chris Fitzpatrick28 March at 03:45 am

    Linda. Surely it’s not the government, but the police and courts who handle criminals. We can’t have the government interfering with our judiciary.

  • Avatar of Julian

    Julian28 March at 12:22 am

    You say that we should vote for a body of work. This Government’s body of work is 3 years of making life more dangerous for Jews, demonising Israel and encouraging and enabling anti-Semitism. Why would I vote for more of that?