Published: 9 November 2021
Last updated: 4 March 2024
DAN COLEMAN: The decision by US activist Sunrise DC to pull out of a rally which would include pro-Israel bodies shines a light on the problematic reflexes that beset the Left
ON OCTOBER 23, a coalition of liberal American organisations came together to sponsor the Freedom to Vote Rally in Washington. They were joined by over 200 kindred organisations, all supporting the Freedom to Vote Act, a Congressional initiative designed to protect voting rights across the US.
Among the expected participants was Sunrise DC, a chapter of the Sunrise Movement, a nationwide youth movement on the frontlines of the fight to stop climate change and in support of the Green New Deal.
But, on October 20, just three days before the event, Sunrise DC stunned the organisers and sent shockwaves through the American Jewish community by pulling out. The rationale for the decision was that one of its issues was support of statehood for the District of Columbia which it viewed as a matter of self-determination.
Sunrise felt that, in this light, it could not share the stage with organisations that espoused Zionism or support for Israel, singling out three participating organisations: the Jewish Council on Public Affairs, National Council of Jewish Women, and The Religious Action Center (RAC) of Reform Judaism.
Sunrise’s statement explained that, in its view, “the fight for statehood and sovereignty are incompatible with Zionism”, entirely disregarding the fact that the three organisations to which they objected all support a two-state solution, i.e. a sovereign state for Palestinians alongside one for Israelis, Zionism being merely the expression of the Israeli part.
Sunrise’s complaint somehow overlooked non-Jewish organisations that are supportive of Israel. As Arno Rosenfield pointed out in Forward, “the coalition includes, for example, the Center for American Progress, which hosted then-Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in 2015, the American Federation of Teachers, which has sent delegations to Israel, and the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, which has released statements supportive of Israel.”




