Published: 18 March 2024
Last updated: 21 March 2024
What is Shabbat Club? Well, the first rule of Shabbat Club is that you talk as much as possible about Shabbat Club to find the people who need it the most.
Who are those people? They’re people like me. People who are culturally and tribally Jewish, but for a multitude of reasons have become disconnected or isolated from the broader Jewish community, whatever that is. These are people who consider themselves to be progressive in their politics and have resided, until now reasonably comfortably, on the left-hand side of the political spectrum.
These are people disgusted by the far-right, extremist government of Benjamin Netanyahu and distressed by the ongoing disenfranchisement and erasure of Palestinians, while also horrified at the barbarity of what took place on October 7.
Those of us who fit into this camp often feel like we are not adequately represented by conservative Jewish organisations and voices, who are often speaking the loudest and from the largest platform. But mainstream leftist spaces have equally left us wounded.
Many of us have spent our lives finding comfort and camaraderie on the left. For years we’ve fought for self-determination for minority groups, for civil rights for all people, for the destruction of binary thinking and binaries around identity. Because these are values that we believe in and for which we want to fight.
And yet, in this space we thought was our political home, we find ourselves swimming in a putrid sea of antisemitism, hatred and ostracism that we simply didn’t see coming. All the rules of engagement we were told to live by, we now see being broken by people we used to consider our friends or peers.
We feel not adequately represented by conservative Jewish organisations but leftist spaces have equally left us wounded.





Comments4
Michele Alberth2 April at 09:18 pm
So we’ll said, Isabella, and true not only for the young ones!
Barbara Weis23 March at 01:26 pm
Great Article Isabelle!
Jessica Lipnack22 March at 04:50 pm
Brilliant and precisely the way I feel. Thank you. By accident, three Jewish friends are coming to dinner tonight so we’ll be part of the SDS—Shabbat Dinner Sisterhood (not the SDS of yore that our old Anti-Vietnam activists remember).
Jane Wilkinson22 March at 04:36 pm
You’ve expressed exactly my dilemma and how I’ve been feeling these last few months. Thank you so much for the article