Aa
  • Read, Watch, Listen
  • TJI Series
  • Community Action
  • Events
  • Zedi
Follow us and continue the conversation
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Test yourself with the TJI Quiz!

Adjust size of text

Aa

Follow us and continue the conversation

  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube

Your saved articles

You haven't saved any articles

What are you looking for?

Original reporting, insightful analysis and diverse views, delivered straight to your inbox

  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Your support fuels our mission to inform, entertain and inspire.

The Jewish Independent is bound by the Standards of Practice of the Australian Press Council. If you believe the Standards may have been breached, you may approach The Jewish Independent or make a complaint to the Australian Press Council in writing at www.presscouncil.org.au. The Council may also be contacted on 1800 025 712.

  • Our Story
  • Contact us
  • Our Team
  • Support us
  • Guidelines
  • Pitch your idea
  • Republishing us
  • Community Action
  • Our Awards
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Aboriginal FlagTorres Strait Islanders Flag

The Jewish Independent acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the Traditional Owners and Custodians of Country throughout Australia. We pay our respects to Elders past and present, and strive to honour their rich history of storytelling in our work and mission.

© The Jewish Independent 2026All Rights Reserved
Website design and development by Your Creative, MelbourneTerms & ConditionsPrivacy Policy
HomeRead, Watch, ListenAustralia
Israel Hamas WarFeatureAustralia

Israel denies starvation in Gaza, Australian J-com leaders say it’s real

In an emphatic rejection of the Israeli government’s denial, community leaders, rabbis, advocates and politicians call for urgent action to alleviate starvation and malnutrition.
Michael Visontay
Print this
A charity distributes meals to Palestinians facing food shortages

A charity distributes meals to Palestinians facing food shortages amid ongoing Israeli attacks and severe restrictions in Gaza City, Gaza on July 28, 2025 (Photo by Ali Jadallah/Anadolu via Getty Images).

Published: 29 July 2025

Last updated: 30 July 2025

Australian Jewish advocacy groups, community leaders and politicians have rejected the Israeli government’s denial that people in Gaza are starving, with responses across the political spectrum calling for urgent assistance to Palestinians who are suffering from lack of food and medicine.

As reports and images of Palestinians dying from malnutrition spread across global media last week, The Jewish Independent approached more than a dozen Jewish groups and prominent individuals for comment about the catastrophe. Only a few had previously spoken out or taken action in response to the unfolding crisis.

However, all those who responded to TJI’s approach – regardless of their political disposition – acknowledged that the starvation was real and that urgent action needs to be taken. While there were marked differences in relation to who they hold responsible for the catastrophe, their responses collectively expressed an emphatic rejection of the denial issued yesterday by Israel’s Deputy Ambassador to Australia.

In a media briefing in Canberra, Amir Meron told journalists that claims of starvation amounted to Hamas propaganda and relied on “false pictures” presenting a distorted view of the situation in Gaza.

“We don’t recognise any famine or any starvation in the Gaza Strip,” Meron said. “This is a false campaign that is being [led] by Hamas, taking advantage of sick children in order to show a false claim and false presentation of hunger and starvation."

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, speaking to colleagues in Canberra on Tuesday, described the embassy's denial of the starvation as "beyond comprehension", the Sydney Morning Herald reported.

The PM repeated his criticisms of Hamas’ role in prolonging the conflict but again implored Israel to end the violence. “While there is a caveat on any information provided by Hamas, it is Israel that has prevented any journalists getting in. Those claims that there is no starvation are beyond comprehension.”

The majority of Jewish advocacy and community leaders who spoke to TJI assigned primary responsibility for the starvation in Gaza at the hands of Hamas. However, even the staunchest of pro-Israel advocate groups did not deny the existence of starvation.

“Despite many months of crying wolf from international agencies making claims about imminent mass starvation in Gaza that proved to be false, we are now seeing evidence of malnutrition and credible reports of starvation in some parts of Gaza that are distressing and very concerning,” said Colin Rubenstein, Executive Director of AIJAC.

“AIJAC calls on the UN agencies to work with Israel so aid can be distributed effectively across Gaza, and end their refusal to cooperate with the GHF [Gaza Humanitarian Foundation], which is offering to distribute all the aid piled up on the border if the UN will only let it. We call on Israel to urgently do what it can to increase the aid being distributed through the GHF, and to safely accommodate more aid through UN agencies.

“However, the fact remains that ultimate responsibility for the continuation of the war that has led to this terrible situation remains with the terror group that started it and refuses to end it – Hamas."

Zionist Federation of Australia said, “Like all Australians, we are deeply distressed by the human suffering in Gaza, and we welcome increased humanitarian aid."

CEO Alon Cassuto added: “Australians care deeply about the human suffering in Gaza, and so do we. The recent improvement in humanitarian access is a welcome step. But a meaningful improvement in both humanitarian conditions and regional security will only be possible once all hostages are released and Hamas relinquishes power.” 

Daniel Aghion, President of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry: "We agree with the PM about the humanitarian imperatives, and welcome the measures announced by Israel to ensure the free flow of aid into Gaza. We also welcome the PM’s acknowledgement that Hamas is not only holding Israeli hostages, it is also holding the people of Gaza hostage by needlessly prolonging the conflict.

"Recognition of a Palestinian state can only mean something when there is a single Palestinian government in control of its territory. Hamas continues to be the single biggest obstacle to achieving that goal. Until then, any form of recognition would merely be an exercise in symbolism."

Rabbi Benjamin Elton, Chief Rabbi of the Great Synagogue, speaking in a personal capacity, said: “Regardless of who is responsible for the starvation currently occurring in Gaza, it is clear to me that Israel has a moral obligation to do everything that is possible and reasonable to alleviate it. At the moment that means flooding Gaza with food, and that should be done immediately.

“I am not naive. Hamas will attempt to steal this food and be successful in stealing some of it, maybe a great deal of it. Nevertheless, the impact of malnutrition is now so severe on the population of Gaza, that there is no alternative but to send in very large amounts of food as quickly as possible. The Gaza Humanitarian Fund is evidently not being successful in bringing sufficient aid into Gaza, which means another approach must be adopted.

“It is true that Hamas and others are attempting to dissuade Gazans from utilising non-UN humanitarian aid, sometimes with violence. Hamas does not care if the people of Gaza starve, in fact they welcome it for propaganda purposes. However, it remains Israel’s moral duty, particularly as a Jewish State, to provide enough food and water so that there should be no starvation in Gaza."

Rabbi Allison Conyer, Senior Rabbi Temple Beth Israel, in Melbourne: “My heart breaks for the innocent who are suffering in Gaza. There is no excuse for starving children. I empathise with Palestinian parents who simply want to feed and protect their children. Likewise, I feel an overwhelming sense of sadness for the ongoing trauma in Israel and the 50 innocent hostages still in captivity…. As human beings, we are wired to provide food, shelter, and safety for our young — a truth that transcends all sides.”

Rabbi Jacqui Ninio, from the Emanuel Synagogue in Sydney: “The now critical humanitarian situation in Gaza is heartbreaking and demands our moral and religious attention. One of the central principles in Judaism is the obligation to save life. So significant is it, that it overrides nearly every other commandment and compels us to act with urgency and compassion when a life is at risk. This means the mobilisation of large-scale aid and ensuring its immediate delivery throughout Gaza by whatever means possible. It is important that this happens as we continue to demand the immediate release of the hostages and a path towards ending the war and a just and lasting peace for all.” 

Rabbi Ralph Genende, Consultant Rabbi Jewish Care, Kehillat Kesher Rabbi: "We need to shout out that Israel recognise that mass hunger in Gaza cannot be part of its just war as Jewish tradition specifies. When the threat of such hunger becomes real, Israel should always respond with alacrity. We also need to speak out about how our enemies are so quick to distort the facts and our erstwhile friends are too fast to accept pro-Hamas fiction.

"We need to remind our fellow Australians that Hamas can end this war they started and stop the hunger they initiated at any time."

Lynda Ben Menashe, President of the National Council of Jewish Women Australia: “As human beings and as mothers, it is impossible for us not to feel outrage and deep distress about the ongoing suffering and deprivation in Gaza - both of Palestinians and of the remaining Israeli and other nationality hostages still being held there under unimaginable conditions.

“From this distance and with the extent of misinformation, disinformation and propaganda flooding our media, we can never know the whole truth of the situation. But we do know that the ultimate responsibility for all of it lies with Hamas, their backers and their accomplices, including the UN.

“At the same time, the silence of the Israeli government about the suffering and the inciteful comments of some members of that government are completely at odds with our Jewish values. The hostages must be released, more aid must be delivered and distributed, and the war must end - all immediately."

Kate Rosenberg, CEO of New Israel Fund Australia, pointed TJI to the fundraising campaign NIF launched last week to help get aid into Gaza. “As Jews, we’re taught that to save one life is to save an entire world. It's because of this teaching that we cannot stay silent as the humanitarian crisis in Gaza escalates to unprecedented levels of suffering,” Rosenberg wrote in an email to members on Friday.

“We have worked to identify three trusted partners (World Central Kitchen, Clean Shelter, Standing Together’s Humanitarian Guard) who are reporting successful delivery and distribution of aid inside Gaza…. A better future for everyone in the region depends on the recognition that safety, dignity, and freedom must belong to all. Right now, the urgent task is to help end the starvation and suffering in Gaza.”

Josh Burns, Labor Member for Macnamara: “It is a deeply held Jewish value to feed those who need it. Food and medical aid must be provided to the people of Gaza.

“When there is so much suffering, pointing fingers does not help. Israel has a moral and legal obligation to do everything in its power to ensure people in Gaza have access to the very basic needs of food, water and medicine.”

Julian Leeser, the Liberal Member for Berowra in northern Sydney, said the Coalition placed responsibility for the starvation on Hamas. "The Coalition is concerned about the worsening humanitarian situation in Gaza. Delays in aid are unacceptable, it’s essential that aid reaches those who need it. However, the Albanese Government’s statement and their decision to blame Israel ignores the central problem: Hamas. 

“Israel must continue their work with international bodies to ensure humanitarian support gets through, but the right system must be in place so that it can be distributed without Hamas intervening in the process."

Independent member for Wentworth, Allegra Spender, in Sydney’s eastern suburbs, was one of the few to sheet responsibility to Israel when she spoke out last Friday. “To see images of people who desperately need aid and not getting what they need is horrific – including deaths of people seeking - this is horrific,” Spender told Sky News.

“While absolutely Hamas must be held to account, Israel has taken on the aid distribution, and Israel now needs to make sure that those people can receive the aid they need, and they can do safely.”

Robert Gregory, CEO of the Australian Jewish Association: “False claims of imminent famine have been made since 9 October 2023. That said, it does appear that there are now hungry people in Gaza and nobody wants to see people starving. What is certain is the cruel starvation endured by Israeli hostages in Gaza.

“The solution remains as it has from day one: Hamas can end the war by surrendering and releasing the hostages. Anyone who genuinely seeks peace or has concerns about the situation in Gaza should pressure Hamas.”

Sarah Schwartz, Co-CEO of the Jewish Council of Australia: “Israel is starving Gaza to death. As Jews who were taught ‘never again’, we can’t look away. Our members are crying out for Australia’s leaders to show moral leadership by taking action to support the delivery of humanitarian aid and ending Israel’s impunity through sanctions and an arms embargo. Our Jewish tradition teaches us the sanctity of human life. We’ll continue to raise our voices no matter the cost.” 

TJI also approached Rabbi Gabi Kaltmann, Chief Rabbi at the Ark Centre, and Rabbi Levi Wolff, Chief Rabbi at Central Synagogue. They did not respond.

READ ALL RESPONSES IN FULL

You might also like
  • Tame apologises – but with little grace
    Deborah Stone
  • Confronting Richard Flanagan and the myth of the Israel lobby
    Mary Garden
  • UK’s dramatic policy change on Israel-Palestine
    Colin Shindler
logomark.67a07ee3
We believe in the free flow of information

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, by using our Creative Commons licence

You might also like

    Woman with land and houses behind her
    NewsAustralia

    Australia to increase sanctions against West Bank settlements

    Deborah Stone
    Apple & rotten core Rosh hashanah
    EditorialAustralia

    Facing a new year with the knowledge life can be better

    The Jewish Independent
    Albanese Bondi
    Royal CommissionAnalysisAustralia

    Prime minister’s absence exposes weakness in Royal Commission hearings

    Michael Visontay

Comments3

  • Avatar of Rachel Sussman

    Rachel Sussman2 August at 02:20 pm

    How sad and disheartening it is for me to see our community and its leaders succumbing to the propaganda of ‘starvation’ in Gaza.
    Their calls in the manner in which done, to me demonstartes nothing but a total lack of faith in ourselves, in our people, in who we are, in Israel ( even with a right wing Government), and in the IDF…
    War is for sure hell and suffering in war cannot be denied, it is undoubtful that the people of Gaza are experiencing hardships ( hardships, not starvation), equally, the people in Israel are experiencing hardships…
    So calling on the end of suffering is indeed a humane call… But the way the statements have been done nit only feed the hand of Hamas and do nothing to help the situation, they further demonise Israel… One would think we Jews have learned lessons of the past, wouldvshow courage in standing for ourselves, but it seems we have not, it seems we would rather believe all the lies than have faith in who we are… well count me out…
    I do not want to see the people of Gaza suffer, I do not want to see the people of Israel suffer, I do not want to see the hostages suffer – they are the ones deprived of food and medicine and any humanitarian aid/ visit…
    I would think that our leaders should have shown more courage, determination and above all – more self belief…
    They should indeed speak up, but they should speak up to demand an end of suffering all around and not just join the distorted world and add suffering to their own…
    How is it that none of them call on the world to force Hamas into surrender so that all suffering can stop?
    How is it that they do not get together to call on behalf of the hostages, their immense suffering and the suffering of their families?
    How is it that they do not call on behalf of the Israelis who are traumatised and suffering quietly on so many levels?
    Their calls solely on behalf of the people of Gaza should be a call on Hamas and the world it is they and not Israel who are the cause of their hardships ( not starvation!)…
    As it is their calls displays nothing but lack of faith and belief in their own, it is a choice to believe the other rather than their own ( hence again lack of fairh), it is a choice to join the world and abandon Israel…
    It seems that now even Jews around the world and their leaders demonise and blame Israel, express total belief in one sided information and point the fingers towards Israel as if it is the source of all the suffering, as if it is a monster who eagerly allows another to suffer- How sad and disappointed I feel in my community and its leaders!

About the author

Michael Visontay

Michael Visontay

Michael Visontay is Commissioning Editor of TJI and was Editor-in-Chief from 2017-22. Michael is a former Assistant Editor of The Sydney Morning Herald and columnist with The Australian Jewish News. He has written six books, including Who Gave You Permission? with Manny Waks, and Welcome to Wanderland: Western Sydney Wanderers and the Pride of the West. His most recent book is Noble Fragments: the Maverick who broke up the world's greatest book (Scribe, 2024).

More from the author

ReflectionWorld

My memory of Gloria Steinem

NewsAustralia

No action to stop Hezbollah ally beaming antisemitic and anti-Israel content into Australia

NewsAustralia

Beinart takes a wrecking ball to Israel

AnalysisAustralia

Prime minister’s absence exposes weakness in Royal Commission hearings

  • Avatar of Simon Krite

    Simon Krite30 July at 12:41 pm

    It is misleading and frankly disingenuous to keep referring to the “Jewish Council of Australia” as a representative Jewish group. This is not a communal body with democratic legitimacy, historical roots, or any real connection to mainstream Australian Jewry. It is an ideologically fringe activist group that exists solely to provide cover for anti-Israel narratives under the convenient banner of Judaism.

    As for Sarah Schwartz’s statement, equating Jewish moral teachings with a call for sanctions against the Jewish state at a time when it is defending itself against genocidal terror is moral inversion of the highest order. To weaponise “never again” while Hamas still holds hostages, uses civilians as shields, and vows to repeat October 7, is grotesque.

    If Schwartz and her cohort are genuinely concerned about the sanctity of human life, they might start by condemning those who openly glorify martyrdom, indoctrinate children to hate, and prioritise tunnels and rockets over hospitals and food. But that doesn’t fit their narrative.

    the self appointed Jewish Council of Australia speaks only for itself and not for Jews, not for Judaism, and certainly not for the Jewish values it so cynically misquotes.

  • Avatar of Jack Morris

    Jack Morris29 July at 07:08 am

    The sanctimonious response from the Jewish Council of Australia really takes the cake. They put all the pressure on to Israel and completely ignore the central role that has been played in this sorry saga by Hamas, a terrorist organisation that is fundamentally a death cult.
    Giving this despicable organisation a platform here amounts to giving them further credbility that they certainly do not deserve and it will lead to them getting further traction in the wider media landscape to keep demeaning and demonising Israel.