Published: 28 June 2022
Last updated: 5 March 2024
The extraordinary prospect that a synagogue challenge could save abortion rights in the United States is a candle at a dark time
The United States Supreme Court decision to remove women’s right to abortion is a deeply retrograde step which will fall most heavily on the poorest and most disadvantaged women, forced to bear unwanted children into already blighted lives.
Religion, of a peculiarly Christian flavour, is at the heart of the court’s decision on Friday to overturn Roe v Wade and remove the right to abortion which has protected American women for almost 50 years.
Religion has always been a cleft stick in the US. The formal separation of church and state enshrined in the Constitution has provided significant protection, but it has never been as strong as the cultural reality of a nation built on a religious impetus that, metaphorically as well as literally, still stamps God on its currency.
So, it is apt – albeit curious – that a new hope now resides with American Jews. A Florida synagogue has filed a petition to challenge the state’s new abortion law, arguing that it constitutes a violation of freedom of religion for Jewish people.
Rabbi Barry Silver of Congregation L’Dor Va-Dor argues that when required to protect the life or health of the mother, Jewish law mandates abortion. It follows that a law prohibiting abortion prevents Jewish women from exercising a religious right.
It is impossible to discount the impact of a Christian ideology willing to sacrifice the wellbeing of a woman to preserve the foetus she is carrying
Although it has not come to the court before, the argument was made by Rabbi Robert Loewy to the Louisiana legislature in 1990 – and failed to influence the legislators.



