Aa
  • Read, Watch, Listen
  • TJI Series
  • Community Action
  • Events
  • Zedi
Follow us and continue the conversation
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Test yourself with the TJI Quiz!

Adjust size of text

Aa

Follow us and continue the conversation

  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube

Your saved articles

You haven't saved any articles

What are you looking for?

Original reporting, insightful analysis and diverse views, delivered straight to your inbox

  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Your support fuels our mission to inform, entertain and inspire.

The Jewish Independent is bound by the Standards of Practice of the Australian Press Council. If you believe the Standards may have been breached, you may approach The Jewish Independent or make a complaint to the Australian Press Council in writing at www.presscouncil.org.au. The Council may also be contacted on 1800 025 712.

  • Our Story
  • Contact us
  • Our Team
  • Support us
  • Guidelines
  • Pitch your idea
  • Republishing us
  • Community Action
  • Our Awards
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Aboriginal FlagTorres Strait Islanders Flag

The Jewish Independent acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the Traditional Owners and Custodians of Country throughout Australia. We pay our respects to Elders past and present, and strive to honour their rich history of storytelling in our work and mission.

© The Jewish Independent 2026All Rights Reserved
Website design and development by Your Creative, MelbourneTerms & ConditionsPrivacy Policy
HomeRead, Watch, ListenWorld
FeatureWorld

A time for Jews to lead on abortion rights

The Jewish Independent
Print this

Published: 28 June 2022

Last updated: 5 March 2024

The extraordinary prospect that a synagogue challenge could save abortion rights in the United States is a candle at a dark time

The United States Supreme Court decision to remove women’s right to abortion is a deeply retrograde step which will fall most heavily on the poorest and most disadvantaged women, forced to bear unwanted children into already blighted lives.

Religion, of a peculiarly Christian flavour, is at the heart of the court’s decision on Friday to overturn Roe v Wade and remove the right to abortion which has protected American women for almost 50 years.

Religion has always been a cleft stick in the US. The formal separation of church and state enshrined in the Constitution has provided significant protection, but it has never been as strong as the cultural reality of a nation built on a religious impetus that, metaphorically as well as literally, still stamps God on its currency.

So, it is apt – albeit curious – that a new hope now resides with American Jews. A Florida synagogue has filed a petition to challenge the state’s new abortion law, arguing that it constitutes a violation of freedom of religion for Jewish people.

Rabbi Barry Silver of Congregation L’Dor Va-Dor argues that when required to protect the life or health of the mother, Jewish law mandates abortion. It follows that a law prohibiting abortion prevents Jewish women from exercising a religious right.

It is impossible to discount the impact of a Christian ideology willing to sacrifice the wellbeing of a woman to preserve the foetus she is carrying

Although it has not come to the court before, the argument was made by Rabbi Robert Loewy to the Louisiana legislature in 1990 – and failed to influence the legislators.

An interfaith alliance submitted an amicus brief to the Court in December which included Jewish, Muslim and some liberal Christian advocacy for the freedom of religion argument: Islam, like Judaism, prioritises the well-being of the mother over that of the foetus.

Most Jewish and Muslim authorities only accept abortion under limited circumstances, but they recognise the complexities of life that blanket bans do not. As Rabbi Danny Schiff wrote recently in The Jewish Independent: Abortion is not a right in Judaism but nor is it always wrong.

The freedom of religion argument is a very different angle from the one on which abortion rights have previously turned in the US. Roe v Wade protected the right to abortion as an aspect of the constitutional protection of the right to privacy.

In overturning Roe v Wade, the Supreme Court argued that the right to privacy does not imply a right to abortion, noting that there is no specific protection of abortion in the constitution.

Freedom of religion, on the other hand, is specifically protected in the Constitution so, if it is successfully argued that abortion is protected under this clause, it is potentially a much more robust protection.

There is something fundamentally wrong about resting the right to bodily integrity of half the population on freedom of religion for a minority. It reveals the deep problems with a constitution written by a bunch of white Christian men in the 18th Century and difficult to amend.

If the Equal Rights Amendment, which formally protects the rights of women, had ever passed perhaps the argument could have been made for all the people its success would protect.

But the reality is that religion plays an important role in why this decision was made. It is significant that four of the five justices who voted to overturn Roe v Wade are Catholic and the fifth was raised Catholic and remains Christian. The two Jews on the Court – Stephen Breyer and Elana Kagan – voted to uphold abortion rights.

Conservative Christians clearly drove the passing of the Mississippi law which was at stake in Dobbs v Jackson Women’s Health Organization, the test case in question. Twenty-six other states are now expected to ban or severely limit abortion, meaning women who do not have the resources to travel, sometimes across most of the country, will be unable to access abortion.

While it would be going too far to argue that the justices depended purely on their private religious convictions or were swayed wholly by religious campaigners, it is impossible to discount the impact of a Christian ideology which argues life begins at conception and is willing to sacrifice the wellbeing of a woman to preserve the foetus she is carrying.

That's not to say the Jewish context is immune from problems. Although abortion is generally available in Israel, women must justify their need before a panel and there are fears that, if a Government beholden to the religious right is returned, the American attitude may infect Israel.

If the United States is to continue to carry the flame of liberty for all Americans – women and men, Jews and Christians, poor as well as rich ­– the freedom of religion case must be won and the right to abortion reinstated.

READ MORE

Jews challenge US abortion law over freedom of religion (The Jewish Independent)

To Jews abortion is not a right, nor always wrong  (Plus 61J)

U.S. Jewish Leaders Decry Supreme Court's Nixing of Abortion Rights as 'Moral Failure' (Haaretz)

The Torah protects a woman's right to abortion and its wrong for American Christians to pretend otherwise (Jewish Chronicle)

American Jews 'outraged' over Supreme Court's Roe v. Wade overturn (Jerusalem Post)

Roe v. Wade Reversal: Israel's Next Election Will Determine if 'It Can Happen Here' (Haaretz)

After Roe reversal, Israel's end-of-pregnancy panels come under scrutiny (Times of Israel)

Photo: Protestors invoke the image of the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the famously liberal Jewish judge who strongly supported women’s right to abortion (AAP)

You might also like
  • We need to talk about cancer risk 
    David Adler
  • The goring ox: who answers for ‘rogue’ AI?
    Yoni Genende
  • Synagogue and Jewish-owned shops damaged in French riots
    Ilan Bloom
logomark.67a07ee3
We believe in the free flow of information

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, by using our Creative Commons licence

You might also like

    Brazilian presidents
    AnalysisWorld

    Brazilian Jews treated as pawns in presidential election

    Karina Stange Calandrin
    Eisenkot Herzog
    Israel Votes 2026NewsIsrael

    Diaspora Jews urge Israel’s change bloc to form a Jewish–Arab coalition

    Sharon Offenberger 2
    Mothin Ali UK Greens
    NewsWorld

    British Greens equate Zionism with racism

    Ruth Eglash 1

About the author

The Jewish Independent

The Jewish Independent

More from the author

‘This $50 is for your grave, you f***ing Jew’

EditorialIsrael

Normality or Sparta: Israel’s choice could hardly be clearer

NewsAustralia

‘The Jewish Independent’ commentary makes finals in Walkley journalism awards

NewsIsrael

Parties, polls, processes: detailed election guide