Published: 26 October 2018
Last updated: 4 March 2024
Increasingly I find the need for threats or bribery for basic requests such as attending shule, asking them to sing Shalom Aleichem on Friday night, or getting them to help build the sukkah. I never wanted them to feel that being part of the rich cycle of Jewish life was a punishment. I had hoped that the exposure to Jewish education would enhance an appreciation of, and connection with, their heritage.
My husband insists it’s just their way of asserting their independent teenage identities as part of the natural separation process from their parents. He is confident that with time they will come back to all that they have learned, and even appreciate it.
Ironically, my teenage rebellion was becoming more Orthodox: starting to keep kosher, becoming shomer shabbat, a madricha for Bnei Akiva (etc). I didn’t realise at the time that was my way of asserting my own identity at public school, rather than the more traditional route of drugs and alcohol.
In hindsight, my parents were very good natured about the electrical timers, kosher meat and pre-torn toilet paper.
I like the ritual of Jewish life and cherish the connection to generations that came before me, who also practiced these traditions - building a temporary dwelling, getting together as a family every Friday night, the lights of Chanukah, eating matzah, making challah, etc.
Yet many years ago, I came to the conclusion that all religion was a patriarchal construct developed to keep societies running smoothly. God’s role in all of it was pretty questionable.
I believe you can be Jewish and still question God’s existence or “his rules as interpreted by man”. I have tried to have open minded conversations with the kids about it, who insist they are atheists.
Part of the problem is that if some of it is up for question, how do you then not throw out the baby with the bath water? Traditionally, our teachings are very clear in their condemnation of homosexuality. Our family chooses to disregard this seemingly antiquated attitude, but that then opens a Pandora’s box. Why keep kosher only because it’s prescribed in the Torah?
Our teachings are very clear in their condemnation of homosexuality. Our family chooses to disregard this seemingly antiquated attitude, but that then opens a Pandora’s box. Why keep kosher only because it’s prescribed in the Torah?
Sometimes I think it would be easier to be more stringent in all of our halachic practices and that way there would be less ambiguity over what is and isn’t important or allowed. But if I myself don’t believe that everything is the word of God, then how can I expect my kids to follow these traditions and dictates?
This struck me most clearly on Yom Kippur. Usually by Mincha or N’eilah, the slight light-headedness from fasting helps me feel spiritual. Despite the beautiful new synagogue, this time the prayers just felt repetitive and left me feeling rather uninspired. My brain kept wandering to think generally bad thoughts about others around me.
Repeatedly intoning and praising God seemed empty and meaningless and I questioned why I was in synagogue. My kids had been questioning all day why they needed to be there.
They continued to complain when I insisted they come to shule for Sukkot and Simchat Torah, too. The compromise was that they bring their books and read during services. Somehow, I have convinced myself that they might pick something up by osmosis, and that some positive associations can be formed without opening their prayer books.
Their complete lack of interest in engaging in not just the service, but most of the aspects of daily Jewish life, upsets me.
Sometimes I think I shouldn’t force them to do things they clearly don’t want to do. But I am pretty sure that if I left it up to them, they wouldn’t choose to do anything, and that makes me really sad. I want them to create their own meaningful connection to their religion and heritage, and can recognise that it doesn’t have to look exactly like mine.
Ultimately, I try and be a role model to them about how to be a good person as that to me is the core of what religion is about. However, they are very adept at focusing on my shortcomings, rather than any of the good things I do.
I am trying to focus on the positives so do see glimmers of hope in their continued interest in attending their youth movements. I do hope that at some point some of their Judaism, whether it be from school, friends or youth movement can even be openly welcomed in our home.
Illustration: John Kron



