Published: 11 March 2024
Last updated: 21 March 2024
How do you reconcile absolute and non-absolute human rights? VIC ALHADEFF asks former Human Rights Commissioner ED SANTOW.
The youngest son of a giant of the law – NSW Supreme Court Justice Kim Santow and social worker Lee - Ed Santow blended key aspects of both parents’ careers. “A judge who is 6ft 4 is pretty imposing, but Dad didn’t wear his height in an overbearing way,” he points out laconically.
“The distance between law and social work isn’t that far. As a lawyer, a client often comes to you at a time of crisis. If you respond in a legalistic way, answering the legal question only, perhaps you’ve fulfilled your narrow duty as a lawyer, but most clients bring a tangle of concerns.
“Disentangling that knot and getting to the heart of the issue is essential. A social worker, on the other hand, zooms out to look at the bigger situation. We need to integrate both worlds. That message was one that Dad applied, and it stuck with me.”
Armed with a Master of Laws from Cambridge University, Santow served as Australia's Human Rights Commissioner from 2016-21, leading its work on freedom of expression, national security, counterterrorism, torture, artificial intelligence (AI), refugees and the LGBTQI+ sector.
Emphasising that human rights are designed to compete with each other, he notes that “the right to free speech and the right to privacy pull in different directions. The question is how to reconcile those rights. You can’t allow one to swamp the other.”
“There are two categories of human rights,” he says – “absolute and non-absolute. Freedom from torture, for example, is an absolute; there is no situation where it’s acceptable under international human rights law.




