Published: 30 October 2018
Last updated: 4 March 2024
They see him as a leader who stirs hatred, incites against minorities and immigrants and attacks the democratic system and freedom of the press. And when it became evident that Israelis tend to support and even admire Trump and what he represents - American Jews were pushed into another level of frustration and anger.
These conflicted feelings came to a head over the weekend with the horrific shooting in Pittsburgh. Israelis, leaders and the public, responded immediately with empathy and solidarity toward the news coming from Pittsburgh. Commentators were rushed to the radio and television stations, Israelis living in Pittsburgh were interviewed and condolence statements were coming from all directions.
There is no doubt that when Jews are under physical attack, the expressions of empathy coming from Israel are genuine. Scenes like those coming out of Pittsburgh evoke a sense of unity that transcend ideology and political differences.
But this is not enough. The relations between Israelis and the largest Jewish community outside of Israel are far from being based on empathy and solidarity. Israelis are divided into two basic attitudes toward American Jewry.
Israelis who tend to be associated with the political right and with Orthodox Judaism tend to be critical and dismissive of the main expressions of American Jews: political liberalism and religious pluralism. And on the other side, Israelis who lean toward the left and are secular, tend to be uninterested in American Jewish life and their attitude is generally of indifference.
More so, Israelis have shown little interest and poor ability to understand the complexity of the existential situation of American Jewry in the era of Trump. Many Israelis relate to America with the simplistic criterion: what is good for Israel. In this context, Trump is viewed as a friend and ally and what he does in America is not of interest.
At the same time, the vast majority of American Jews are appalled by their president and the toxic climate that has prevailed in America since he was elected. America is deeply divided and full of explosive fumes, incitement, fear and lack of trust in the other. Most American Jews are on the liberal side of the scale and they despise the president and the atmosphere that he promotes.
And when they look toward Israel and see the expressions of admiration toward Trump and his anti-democratic tendencies they are going out of their minds with frustration. The Pittsburgh massacre is now pushing American Jews to an even more difficult place.
This is a time for Israelis to awaken, to extend an arm, to relate to the Jewishness of American Jews with respect (and it is important to remember that the killing took place during religious activities in a liberal synagogue), to understand the political sensitivity that exists in America today, and to withhold before they cheer Trump. This is the time to remember that American Jewry is our most significant ally in the project of Jewish renaissance in modern times.
And a final note: the murderer wrote in his statements that the act in the synagogue was in reaction to the work of HIAS, the veteran Jewish organisation that supports (legal) refugees who arrive in America. A few weeks ago, I visited the offices of HIAS in New York with a delegation of Israeli journalists. There, we heard again, that being Jewish in America is about social justice, helping the needy and fighting for civil liberties.
Photo by Alexandra Wilmley/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
ELAN EZRACHI'S LETTERS FROM NEW YORK
Renewal rhymes with cool: Young Jews want to live in hip centres
‘Embarrassment mixed with despair’: How US liberal Jews feel about Trump and Israel


