Published: 14 May 2018
Last updated: 4 March 2024
What is your attitude to the significance of May 15?
NAHED ODEH
I recognise May 15 as an ongoing Nakba for all Palestinian people. It is the catastrophe that has left the Palestinians away from their homes, lands and memories. It is the day which reminded us of the occupation and the settlers who are taking over our home land. Each year I remember the day with a hope that another day of freedom is coming soon, and we will never forget.
GEORGE HATOUM
The Al-Nakba is the ongoing suffering, pain, discrimination and injustice that the Palestinians continue to suffer since May 15, 1948 till today. Every day is a Nakba till there is peace with justice. The irony is that the suffering of Palestinians is on the hands of the people that probably suffered the most in the last 2000 years.
MUNTHER EMAD
I was born in a Palestinian refugee camp (on Yom Kippur) to parents who were dispossessed of their land. My feelings about Nakba Day have changed over the course of my journey as a migrant. My journey has enabled me to gain a deeper understanding of what it must have been like for my parents and grandparents.
Because the majority of Palestinians over there focus on survival, they have never had the chance to heal. Living in a healthy life here, and reclaiming my well-being, has enabled me to understand the trauma.
What personal or family experiences in the Occupied Territories shaped your views?
NAHED ODEH
I was a kid when the Israeli soldiers came to our home to arrest my brother who was 14 years old. I still remember the way they knocked at the main gate and their loud voice. At this time, I was afraid and shaking, but this event made me stronger and I would spend the rest of my life asking for a free Palestine. I am not any more afraid of these soldiers. This event made me feel mature, that we are the rightful owners of the land and that no one can stop us.
GEORGE HATOUM
My father, his sister and parents (my grandparents) all died in exile, in the squalid conditions of the refugee camps of Lebanon having never seen my father’s two sisters who were left behind in the mayhem and violence of 1948. They were never allowed to even visit their siblings/children or their homes, let alone return to their family or properties.
MUNTHER EMAD
I sensed from an early age that something was not right. My parents, with little means, were looking after 15 kids. My grandfather was killed on his farming land in 1948, on Nakba Day. He refused to leave his land and was found lying on the ground, dead. We think he was killed by Israeli forces, although it was never officially confirmed. My grandmother left him on the farm, with her two sons and daughter, pursuing her own instinct for survival. From the refugee camp she traded goods in her home town of Beersheba, which helped my father who didn’t have much work. That’s how she saw how she could fix what had happened to her.
My aunt died of disease; the other son got lost and did not know where he was for many years. We eventually found him living in Syria.
I participated in the first Intifida. I was 12 years of age, I threw stones, I saw my brothers being injured, my mum beaten, and I was also beaten by Israeli soldiers. Once my dad was humiliated by the soldiers. There were times when I did not see the soldiers as human beings, rather as machines. When my best friend was 13 he was shot in the head with a rubber bullet, which killed him. That was when the Intifada became tragic for me.
At the end of my secondary schooling, I was accepted as a humanitarian case by Bethlehem university, where I studied psychology and sociology. This was start of a huge transformation from a teenager to an adult.
[gallery size="large" ids="19700,19701"]
What do you think the current Israeli and Palestinian leaderships should be doing to end the Occupation?
NAHED ODEH
I don’t think there is anything that both leaders can do. I think they have reached a dead end. The peace process has passed away and the negotiation is in coma.
GEORGE HATOUM
The Palestinian leadership should stop all co-operation with the state of Israel and encourage BDS to put pressure on Israel to stop all the acts that is causing the two- state solution to die the death of one thousand cuts.
The settlements housing 800,000 Jewish-only settlers, as well as the infrastructure including the Jewish-only roads, should be dismantled or made accessible and available to all. This will allow either the two- states to be viable or have one democratic bi-national state. In short, both sides should do everything possible to end the occupation, end the racist laws that allow one group privileges over any other and compensate all victims of injustice.
MUNTHER EMAD
Both of them have failed miserably. I hold the Israeli state sole responsible for what has happened. It is more powerful; the Israelis could fix the situation with less risk to their survival. There have also been mistakes on the Palestinian side but you can’t hold the victims responsible for what happened.
Palestinians need to move forward for the sake of their next generations. We also need to understand the full background of the Israeli state, especially the Holocaust. But in return, Israel needs to develop more compassion for the Palestinians. “Never again” does not just apply for Jews but for all human beings.
Dr Nahed Odeh is a lawyer from east Jerusalem who has a PhD in constitutional law from UNSW, proposing a constitutional design for contemporary Palestine, She works as a researcher and political analyst
Dr George Hatoum is a family doctor who was born in St Elias refugee camp Lebanon. He is an executive member of the Australia Palestine Advocacy Network
Munther Emad was born in a refugee camp in Gaza, studied psychology at Bethlehem University and now runs intervention and rehabilitation programs works in the NSW criminal justice system
Photo: Arab refugees on the Lebanon Road after fleeing their homes in the Galilee during fighting between Israeli and Arab forces, November 1948 (AP)
