Aa
  • Read, Watch, Listen
  • TJI Series
  • Community Action
  • Events
  • Zedi
Follow us and continue the conversation
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Test yourself with the TJI Quiz!

Adjust size of text

Aa

Follow us and continue the conversation

  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube

Your saved articles

You haven't saved any articles

What are you looking for?

Original reporting, insightful analysis and diverse views, delivered straight to your inbox

  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Your support fuels our mission to inform, entertain and inspire.

The Jewish Independent is bound by the Standards of Practice of the Australian Press Council. If you believe the Standards may have been breached, you may approach The Jewish Independent or make a complaint to the Australian Press Council in writing at www.presscouncil.org.au. The Council may also be contacted on 1800 025 712.

  • Our Story
  • Contact us
  • Our Team
  • Support us
  • Guidelines
  • Pitch your idea
  • Republishing us
  • Community Action
  • Our Awards
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Aboriginal FlagTorres Strait Islanders Flag

The Jewish Independent acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the Traditional Owners and Custodians of Country throughout Australia. We pay our respects to Elders past and present, and strive to honour their rich history of storytelling in our work and mission.

© The Jewish Independent 2026All Rights Reserved
Website design and development by Your Creative, MelbourneTerms & ConditionsPrivacy Policy
HomeRead, Watch, Listen

The religious challenge at the heart of Israel’s deportation debate

Ittay Flescher
Print this

Published: 6 March 2018

Last updated: 4 March 2024

FOR ANYONE FOLLOWING the debate around the fate of 37,800 mostly Sudanese and Eritreans in Israel over the past year, one could easily be fooled into thinking that this is a debate between the religious Right and secular Left.

On the religious Right, there are calls for the immediate deportation of all the “infiltrators,” which are supported to varying degrees by the majority of parties in the Knesset. Interior Minister Aryeh Deri who is the leader of the Sephardi Orthodox Shas party, said last month:

"We are now embarking on the big operation of expatriating infiltrators into a third country, and there are only two options for infiltrators: voluntary deportation or indefinite detention.” He concluded by quoting the famous dictum from the Babylonian Talmud: “The poor of your city come first'."

On the other side are mostly secularists and left wing MKs who couch their arguments in humanistic and liberal language with many appeals to natural justice and international law. For example, a proposal submitted by opposition MKs Eyal Ben Reuven (Zionist Union), Michal Rozin (Meretz) and Aida Touma-Suleiman (Joint List) noted that until 2013, Israel did not even allow Africans to submit requests for asylum.

Once it consented to such a process, it was conducted with interminable inefficiency, with only a single bureau in the entire country processing requests.

"Of the 15,000 requests submitted, only ten people were afforded the status of refugees. Israel has the lowest recognition rates in the Western world," the opposition members claimed.

"Should the state decide to carry out the expulsion of asylum seekers against their will, it should ascertain who is a refugee and who isn't, and it can only do that by professionally and thoroughly vetting the asylum requests (according to the 1951 UN Refugee Convention)."

In a bid to to add a new observant voice into the debate, last month Kehilat Yedidyam a modern Orthodox congregation in Jerusalem, hosted an event called “A religious voice against deportation and solidarity for the stranger within our midst.”  It was co-sponsored by fellow Orthodox congregations Kehilla Shira Hadasha, and the Masorti Kehilot of Maayonot and Tziyon.

Speaking to The Jewish Independent about the need for the event, Debbie Weissman, who was the moderator on the night and one of the founding members of Yedidya, expressed her regret that “most Orthodox Jews in Israel interpret Jewish laws and values in a narrow and particularist manner concerned only with preserving the Jewish people”.

Her desire for the event was motivated by her belief that “Judaism is also about universalism because our Torah teaches that all humans were created in God’s image”.

She added that observing laws about human rights are as essential to her Judaism as observing Shabbat and kashrut and longed for an Orthodox Judaism in Israel that could find a greater balance so that Israel could be equally Jewish and Democratic. “This place is not much of a Jewish State if it is not a democracy,” she added.

[gallery columns="1" size="medium" ids="17616"]

The first speaker of the night was Rabbi Avital Hochstein, President of Machon Hadar, a Torah education institution, who gave a passionate refutation of  Ayreh Deri’s suggestion that Israel should expel the refugees because “the poor of your city come first”.

Hochstein quoted from the Shulchan Aruch to explain that this is not a command to prioritise the welfare of your own race or religion over others, but rather to prioritise the welfare of those in your geographic space, namely the refugees of south Tel Aviv, over those in other places in the world.

Her presentation was followed by a powerful story from Berhane Negasi, a refugee from Eritrea who recounted the abuse inflicted on “soldiers” who are slaves from the age of 16-65 in the dictatorship that is his country of birth. Negasi’s testimony of how he survived the threats to his life from the Eritreans, Bedouin smugglers and even ISIS left few people in the shule unmoved as to the necessity of Israel providing him sanctuary.

Yedidya member Nicky Lachs, who organised the event, said that “while most religious Jews in Israel are very kind to their own, when it comes to be the lives of others, there is sometimes a different value set in place.”

Lachs did approach other Orthodox Synagogues in Jerusalem to join in hosting the event, but some refused, explaining that they felt they couldn’t be associated with an event that is political in nature.

She was quite perturbed and disappointed by this response, explaining that when Israel is carrying out a decision that will literally put people’s lives in danger, refusing to speak out is akin to collaborating with the policy. She refuses to see this as a left-right issue, instead seeing this as a humanitarian and ethical issue that should find common cause among all religious Jews.
This place is not much of a Jewish State if it is not a democracy. 

The most prominent speaker of the night was former MK Michael Melchior, who has developed a hero status in liberal Orthodox circles over the past decades for his tireless campaigning on behalf of a more humanistic and democratic Israel in traditionally Jewish language.

Melchior concluded his remarks by rejecting a dilemma expressed by Prime Minister Netanyahu in 2010 in a debate about foreign workers. "On the one hand, this problem is a humanitarian problem, we all feel and understand the hearts of children,” said Netanyahu.

“But on the other hand, there are Zionist considerations and ensuring the Jewish character of the State of Israel. We don't want to create an incentive for the inflow of hundreds of thousands of illegal migrant workers."

Netanyahu’s comparison, which continues to be widely held in Israel, asserts that there is a tension between Jewish/Zionist and humanitarian/democratic values. Melchior said these two values need not contradict each other, and explained that if both observant Jews and wider Israeli society are able to reclaim what Judaism and Zionism means that it will be impossible for a Jewish State to continue imprisoning refugees and expelling them to Rwanda.

One can only hope that he is right.

Main photo: Berhane Negasi speaking at Yedidya

All photos taken by Warren Burstein

 
You might also like
  • The Israelis who flew home to vote
    Gideon Cohen
  • Flooding and illness increase urgency of humanitarian relief in Gaza
    Shahar Burla
  • Australia’s latest sanctions raise the stakes, but stay on track
    Deborah Stone
logomark.67a07ee3
We believe in the free flow of information

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, by using our Creative Commons licence

You might also like

    Web Banner – Andrew Casey Internship

    Andrew Casey Memorial Internship Program

    Paul Amato
    Copy of Politica Podcast Social Tiles (600 x 400 px)
    Israel Iran WarPodcastIsrael

    Politica – Israeli Politics Explained

    The Jewish Independent 1
    Australia’s Prime Minister Albanese Speaks After Bondi Shootings
    News

    What PM, Premier, Police say about Bondi antisemitic attack

    The Jewish Independent 1

About the author

Ittay Flescher

Ittay Flescher

Ittay Flescher is the Jerusalem Correspondent for The Jewish Independent. For over 20 years, he has worked as an educator, journalist, and peacebuilder in Melbourne and Jerusalem. His book, The Holy and the Broken: A Cry for Israeli-Palestinian Peace from a Land that Must Be Shared, was longlisted for the 2025 Walkley Book Awards.

More from the author

FeatureArts & Culture

The eight most Jewish songs of Leonard Cohen

OpinionIsrael

Even on October 7, we are not united

AnalysisArts & Culture

Fauda and the illusion of vengeance

AnalysisIsrael

What ‘Zionism’ means in Israel:  it’s not what you think