Published: 14 January 2022
Last updated: 4 March 2024
DEBORAH STONE: A major factor in enabling misconduct is the problematic impulse to conceal its existence. Concern for reputation must not trump transparency
WHILE CHOOSING A school for her daughter, about five years ago, a friend of mine asked the principal of a large Jewish school to outline the school’s bullying policy.
“You don’t need to worry about that,” replied the principal. “We don’t have bullying here.”
The school was promptly and wisely crossed off the parent’s list. Only the most naïve parent would believe such a claim. The principal was either woefully out of touch with the realities of school life or deliberately presenting an impossibly rosy picture to a prospective paying customer. Neither is an indication of a healthy institution.
Unfortunately, the tendency to present our communal institutions as immune from the usual social ills is strong within the Jewish community.
It came under the spotlight last month when The Age reported a case of teacher misconduct. Such cases are always upsetting, but there was an additional issue of concern on this occasion.
The Age reported that Mount Scopus principal Rabbi James Kennard had announced the departure of the teacher with a disingenuous email stating he had “resigned, due to personal reasons” and thanking him for his “great contribution to the college over 23 years”.
Only after the inevitable grapevine spread the information that an independent investigation had substantiated a current allegation and had prompted past students to come forward with similar allegations, did Rabbi Kennard notify the school community about the concerns.
According to the Age, “at least 10 women have accused the former senior teacher of misconduct towards them, when they were students”.



