Aa
  • Read, Watch, Listen
  • TJI Series
  • Community Action
  • Events
  • Zedi
Follow us and continue the conversation
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Test yourself with the TJI Quiz!

Adjust size of text

Aa

Follow us and continue the conversation

  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube

Your saved articles

You haven't saved any articles

What are you looking for?

Original reporting, insightful analysis and diverse views, delivered straight to your inbox

  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Your support fuels our mission to inform, entertain and inspire.

The Jewish Independent is bound by the Standards of Practice of the Australian Press Council. If you believe the Standards may have been breached, you may approach The Jewish Independent or make a complaint to the Australian Press Council in writing at www.presscouncil.org.au. The Council may also be contacted on 1800 025 712.

  • Our Story
  • Contact us
  • Our Team
  • Support us
  • Guidelines
  • Pitch your idea
  • Republishing us
  • Community Action
  • Our Awards
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Aboriginal FlagTorres Strait Islanders Flag

The Jewish Independent acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the Traditional Owners and Custodians of Country throughout Australia. We pay our respects to Elders past and present, and strive to honour their rich history of storytelling in our work and mission.

© The Jewish Independent 2026All Rights Reserved
Website design and development by Your Creative, MelbourneTerms & ConditionsPrivacy Policy
HomeRead, Watch, Listen

What sort of love should Jews have for Israel?

Ittay Flescher
Print this

Published: 23 November 2021

Last updated: 4 March 2024

ITTAY FLESCHER: The Gaza conflict has spawned a new mantra in the Diaspora - unconditional ‘love of the Jewish people’. But what about Jews whose love is nuanced?

THIS ISN’T GOING to be another article about whether diaspora Jews have the right to criticise Israel more than they do any other country. You’ve all read that one before and nothing you read here will change your mind about switching from the camp you have chosen.

In the past the terms that have characterised this debate have been “loyalty”, “liberalism”, “progressive values” or “tikkun olam” (repairing the world). But all of these terms are about to be dwarfed by a new expression that Jews may be debating for the coming decade.

In the wake of the divisions that emerged following the past Gaza conflict in May, the term that has now come to characterise the debate is “Ahavat Yisrael”. 

It translates literally as “love of Israel” — but has a more pointed meaning:  love of “the Jewish people”, who for centuries before the political state was established in 1948, were known as Israelites.

Not only has the meaning of “Ahavat Yisrael” become the focus of countless sermons, books and speeches in recent months, its definition was also the key focus of a recent, extensive New York Times magazine article about the unravelling of American Zionism.

When Rabbi Shai Held, President of Mechon Hadar in Manhattan, recently asked his friends on Facebook what the phrase conjures up for them, some of the most liked responses from opposite sides of the political spectrum were “love and connection to all of the Jewish people, regardless of differences,” and “a bullying slogan used to silence rebuke”.

As the thread generated more than 100 comments, it became clear that the once ancient term has become conflated with “love of [the modern state of] Israel” in most contexts, with the implication that the modern state of Israel = Jews and that Jews are the primary residents of Israel that Diaspora Jews should feel obligations or affinity towards.

The first example that can be found for this term being used around controversies regarding the Jewish past and present dates back to 1963 when German-born Israeli philosopher Gershom Scholem, the preeminent scholar of Jewish mysticism, wrote to German political philosopher Hannah Arendt:

The Jewish Independent

Ahavat Yisrael has become conflated with 'love of the modern state of Israel', with the implication that the modern state of Israel equals Jews.

“There is something in the Jewish language that is completely indefinable, yet fully concrete—what Jews call ahavath Israel, or love for the Jewish people. With you, my dear Hannah, as with so many intellectuals coming from the German Left, there is no trace of it.”

Arendt replied to Scholem’s accusation with: “Gerhard, can you tell me the history of that term in the tradition?” Scholem never replied. And he was not one to deflect a challenge.

Perhaps he didn’t reply because there is, indeed, no commandment in the Torah toward ahavat Yisrael, even though many rabbis, including the great Maimonides, do see it as an obligation in their commentaries of the verse from Leviticus: “Love your fellow as yourself.”

Yet like the phrase “tikkun olam”, which also has no reference in the Torah, this Biblical absence hasn’t prevented “ahavat Yisrael” from rising above that of the 10 commandments for many Diaspora Jews as a contemporary religious obligation. 

Pushing back against this notion, the editor-in-chief of US magazine Jewish Currents, Arielle Angel, wrote that for progressive Jews like her at this moment in history, it is incumbent to stand with Palestinians before Israelis.

Her reasoning for this is based on a prism that views the key purpose of Judaism as standing with the persecuted people of the world. As anyone who ever spent any time in a synagogue would know, the most repeated verse in the Torah is that one should not oppress the stranger, remembering that “we too were once strangers in the land of Egypt”.

The Jewish Independent

As anyone who ever spent any time in a synagogue would know, the most repeated verse in the Torah is that one should not oppress the stranger.

Angel explained that “Jewishness must mean justice for the Palestinian people or nothing at all. If it is to be drained of meaning, then I will be, too, for a time, and will have to rebuild myself on sand”.

Responding to this description of Jewishness, Yehuda Kurtzer, the North American President of the Shalom Hartman Institute wrote: “To care for other Jews is not evidence of moral hierarchy, and it certainly is not evidence of moral monstrosity.” 

A self-described liberal Zionist, Kurtzer added: “Ahavat Yisrael does not have to be reduced to ethnostatism but might simply be expressed in the empathy we express towards our kin – real or imagined – for their bodies and lives, even when we don’t like their politics.

“The Jewish people are a real people, and not a mythic imaginary; we have to owe something to one another, even during a period of stateness, just as we live and breathe.”

The challenge is to find a more nuanced position between ahavat Yisrael and betrayal, which acknowledges the validity of 'critical love'.

Having grown up in the small mostly Zionist but highly diverse Jewish community of Melbourne, I remember running many programs about the importance of “ahavat Yisrael” in my days as a youth movement leader and Jewish educator at a day school.

In the 1990s, the meaning of the term for me encompassed protesting and advocating for Soviet Jewry, encouraging dialogue between left and right, Sephardim and Ashkenazim and between different denominations of Judaism.

I rarely remember the term being used in any political context about how one should respond to the political decisions of the Israeli government, even at the height of the Oslo Accords process and later the “Gaza Disengagement” where divisions were no less fierce than today’s differences of opinion about Israel.

Having made Jerusalem my home four years ago, I am grateful to no longer need to think twice about how I talk, write and educate about Israel for fear of being accused of lacking sufficient “ahavat Yisrael”. 

I now live in a country where I sometimes feel the national slogan derives from a different verse from Leviticus, the one that states, “Do not hate your brother in your heart, you shall surely rebuke your neighbour” which some interpret as a call to rebuke one’s neighbour face to face rather than keeping criticisms to oneself.

As the centre becomes more silent and the extremes of left and right become ever more vocal, that nuanced voice is increasingly harder to hear.

In today’s Jerusalem, rebuking one’s neighbour in person, on WhatsApp or from one’s car window, is often done several times before lunch. I hope that my fellow Jews who live the diaspora, can collectively find their way to express rebuke and love the Israel of today in a manner that honours and respects the individual differences of all of us.

The challenge for all who care about the future of the Diaspora-Israel relationship is to find a more nuanced position between “ahavat Yisrael” and betrayal, which acknowledges the validity of “critical love”.

But as the centre becomes more silent and the extremes of left and right become ever more vocal, that nuanced voice is increasingly harder to hear.

READ MORE
NADAV TAMIR: Israel’s relations with Diaspora Jewry: Can the rift be healed? A practical start at healing
(Jerusalem Strategic Tribune)

Shas head Arye Dery can’t walk away from Kotel deal he helped make (Haaretz)

Photo: AP

You might also like
  • The Israelis who flew home to vote
    Gideon Cohen
  • Flooding and illness increase urgency of humanitarian relief in Gaza
    Shahar Burla
  • Australia’s latest sanctions raise the stakes, but stay on track
    Deborah Stone
logomark.67a07ee3
We believe in the free flow of information

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, by using our Creative Commons licence

You might also like

    Copy of Politica Podcast Social Tiles (600 x 400 px)
    Israel Iran WarPodcastIsrael

    Politica – Israeli Politics Explained

    The Jewish Independent 1
    Web Banner – Andrew Casey Internship

    Andrew Casey Memorial Internship Program

    Paul Amato
    Feature

    Israel bows to pressure by restoring water flow, ICC investigates both sides

    TJI Wrap

About the author

Ittay Flescher

Ittay Flescher

Ittay Flescher is the Jerusalem Correspondent for The Jewish Independent. For over 20 years, he has worked as an educator, journalist, and peacebuilder in Melbourne and Jerusalem. His book, The Holy and the Broken: A Cry for Israeli-Palestinian Peace from a Land that Must Be Shared, was longlisted for the 2025 Walkley Book Awards.

More from the author

FeatureArts & Culture

The eight most Jewish songs of Leonard Cohen

OpinionIsrael

Even on October 7, we are not united

AnalysisArts & Culture

Fauda and the illusion of vengeance

AnalysisIsrael

What ‘Zionism’ means in Israel:  it’s not what you think