Published: 23 November 2021
Last updated: 4 March 2024
ITTAY FLESCHER: The Gaza conflict has spawned a new mantra in the Diaspora - unconditional ‘love of the Jewish people’. But what about Jews whose love is nuanced?
THIS ISN’T GOING to be another article about whether diaspora Jews have the right to criticise Israel more than they do any other country. You’ve all read that one before and nothing you read here will change your mind about switching from the camp you have chosen.
In the past the terms that have characterised this debate have been “loyalty”, “liberalism”, “progressive values” or “tikkun olam” (repairing the world). But all of these terms are about to be dwarfed by a new expression that Jews may be debating for the coming decade.
In the wake of the divisions that emerged following the past Gaza conflict in May, the term that has now come to characterise the debate is “Ahavat Yisrael”.
It translates literally as “love of Israel” — but has a more pointed meaning: love of “the Jewish people”, who for centuries before the political state was established in 1948, were known as Israelites.
Not only has the meaning of “Ahavat Yisrael” become the focus of countless sermons, books and speeches in recent months, its definition was also the key focus of a recent, extensive New York Times magazine article about the unravelling of American Zionism.
When Rabbi Shai Held, President of Mechon Hadar in Manhattan, recently asked his friends on Facebook what the phrase conjures up for them, some of the most liked responses from opposite sides of the political spectrum were “love and connection to all of the Jewish people, regardless of differences,” and “a bullying slogan used to silence rebuke”.
As the thread generated more than 100 comments, it became clear that the once ancient term has become conflated with “love of [the modern state of] Israel” in most contexts, with the implication that the modern state of Israel = Jews and that Jews are the primary residents of Israel that Diaspora Jews should feel obligations or affinity towards.





