Published: 27 January 2023
Last updated: 5 March 2024
Being patted down by Israeli soldiers at a West Bank protest showed SAM STEIN how violating the weaponisation of security can feel.
Last Friday, I had planned to spend a pleasant morning harvesting vegetables with some Palestinian friends and activists in the South Hebron Hills, also known as Masafer Yatta.
Instead, I found myself being detained and aggressively patted down by several IDF soldiers after attending a protest deemed to be illegal.
Earlier in the week, the army had confiscated dozens of sabra cacti from a Palestinian farmer in the area. The army had subsequently contacted the farmer and informed him that the crops were confiscated by mistake and that they would be returned shortly. However, on Friday, the army went back on this decision, and the farmer was told the cacti would not be returned.
A protest was hurriedly organised on the farmer’s land. A Palestinian activist in the village where I was working asked me to drive him to the protest. I did and, upon arrival, decided to join in the protest and document it.
During the protest, soldiers grabbed posters and Palestinian flags out of demonstrators’ hands, shoved journalists, and eventually fired tear gas. I saw a friend surrounded by soldiers and went over - camera rolling - to see what was happening.
As soon as I was in the vicinity, a soldier began to repeatedly grab my shoulder and demand that I show her my ID. I asked why but she refused to give me a reason, responding with a thinly-veiled threat, “You need to be careful with us.” This phrase was repeated to me by a second soldier, who used the exact same words. The refrain reminded me of the chilling threat made by a soldier in the wake of November’s election, who told an activist, “Ben-Gvir is going to bring order.”
After showing our IDs, my friend and I were taken to a nearby military vehicle where we were once again told to hand over our IDs to comply with a security check. We were then told that we were being detained because we were attending an illegal protest. We were given no warning that this protest was deemed illegal, and this was new information to me.



