Published: 22 April 2022
Last updated: 4 March 2024
Let the Australian election be a battle of ideas around climate, health and the post-Covid recovery - and leave worrying about the Middle East to those who most need to deal with it.
FOR MANY AUSTRALIAN Jews, the State of Israel is much more than another country on the Mediterranean Sea, where the air is sweet and heavy with the memories of history. It’s also a significant part of their Jewish identity and the subject of endless debates on social media and arguments over family meals.
When an Israeli wins a Nobel Prize or Olympic gold medal, the pride felt by an Australian Jew can sometimes be even greater than if the same had happened to an Australian. And when Israel fails to live up to their expectations, as was the case on many occasions throughout the seven-year Malka Leifer trial, their pain and disappointment is equal to that of a beloved child who has lost their way.
It’s therefore not surprising that a candidate’s position on issues relating to Israel’s security is often a factor in determining how many Zionist Australians vote.
Yet in the lead-up to the May 2022 election, Michael Visontay observed this week that one could be excused for thinking half of Australia is Jewish or votes based on Israel’s interests.
As a dual citizen watching this election from my home in Jerusalem, I find this trend to be far more disturbing than comforting. For while I know that the lobbying, pressuring or even cancelling the appearances of candidates at synagogues comes out of concern for my wellbeing as an Israeli, I’m not sure how any of these actions is actually in my interest.
When the status of Palestine as a state, or Jerusalem as a capital becomes a political football that Australian politicians use to wedge one another in public debate, I fail to see how this benefits any of the people who live here.
Talk to anyone living in Israel you quickly discover the term 'pro-Israel' is meaningless in a country where there is little consensus on the most pressing issues we face.




