Aa
  • Read, Watch, Listen
  • TJI Series
  • Community Action
  • Events
  • Zedi
Follow us and continue the conversation
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Test yourself with the TJI Quiz!

Adjust size of text

Aa

Follow us and continue the conversation

  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube

Your saved articles

You haven't saved any articles

What are you looking for?

Original reporting, insightful analysis and diverse views, delivered straight to your inbox

  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Your support fuels our mission to inform, entertain and inspire.

The Jewish Independent is bound by the Standards of Practice of the Australian Press Council. If you believe the Standards may have been breached, you may approach The Jewish Independent or make a complaint to the Australian Press Council in writing at www.presscouncil.org.au. The Council may also be contacted on 1800 025 712.

  • Our Story
  • Contact us
  • Our Team
  • Support us
  • Guidelines
  • Pitch your idea
  • Republishing us
  • Community Action
  • Our Awards
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • FaceBook
  • X
  • YouTube
Aboriginal FlagTorres Strait Islanders Flag

The Jewish Independent acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the Traditional Owners and Custodians of Country throughout Australia. We pay our respects to Elders past and present, and strive to honour their rich history of storytelling in our work and mission.

© The Jewish Independent 2026All Rights Reserved
Website design and development by Your Creative, MelbourneTerms & ConditionsPrivacy Policy
HomeRead, Watch, ListenIsrael
AnalysisIsrael

Analysis: What will a ground invasion of Gaza achieve?

TJI Wrap
Print this

Published: 17 October 2023

Last updated: 5 March 2024

Israel faces tactical, strategic and humanitarian challenges as it prepares to invade Gaza.

Israel is working to create a window of legitimacy for ground attack
Ron Ben-Yisha, Ynet

The IDF continues its preparations for a major Israeli offensive in Gaza and, together with the Shin Bet, is operating on many levels, including air strikes in Gaza, to facilitate ground entry without a heavy price for Israel’s forces.

The airstrikes are intended to disrupt the defence, command and control systems of Hamas, to aid the intelligence effort, and to exact a price from Hamas members, especially from its commanders, for the atrocities they committed in the communities surrounding Gaza.

At the same time, the IDF is working to create a "window of legitimacy" as wide as possible to carry out an effective attack in Gaza. This "window of legitimacy" is intended to give the army time and approval to carry out warfare when it enters Gaza.

The IDF's demand from the residents of the northern Gaza Strip, to evacuate through humanitarian corridors to the south, is the main means of proving to global public opinion and to the Biden administration that Israel is acting within the framework of the international laws of war.

Hamas has also moved into position and is trying to get its fighters in Gaza into planned defensive formations. Hamas political leaders in Lebanon, Turkey and Qatar are trying to expand the fighting to additional arenas  to ease the pressure on the terrorists in Gaza and reduce the Israeli military effort. They are trying to get Hezbollah, the Palestinians in the refugee camps in Lebanon, the Palestinians in the West Bank, and Iran-backed militias, to join the fighting.

Could a ground invasion succeed in destroying Hamas?
Paul Kirby, BBC

Herzi Halevi, Chief of Staff of the Israel Defence Forces (IDF), has vowed to "dismantle" Hamas, and has singled out its political head in Gaza. But is there an ultimate vision for how Gaza will look after 16 years of Hamas's violent rule?

"I don't think Israel can dismantle every Hamas member, because it's an idea of extremist Islam," says military analyst Amir Bar Shalom of Israel's Army Radio. "But you can weaken it as much as you can, so it has no operational capabilities."

Israelis have been warned the war could take months, and a record 360,000 reservists have reported for duty.

The question is how long Israel can continue its campaign without international pressure to pull back.

Gaza is rapidly becoming a "hell hole", the UN's refugee agency has warned. The death toll is rising fast; water, power and fuel supplies have been cut off, and now half of the population is being told to flee large areas.

"The government and military feel they have the backing of the international community - at least Western leaders. The philosophy is 'let's mobilise, we have plenty of time'," says Yossi Melman, one of Israel's leading security and intelligence journalists.

But sooner or later, he believes, Israel's allies will step in if they see images of people starving.

Seizing Gaza will prove very costly to Israel
Daniel Byman and Seth G. Jones, Foreign Affairs

Israel’s immediate military objective will now be to destroy Hamas or at least cripple it severely. Israel will look to kill, capture, or drive underground Hamas’s political and military leadership, and it will try to demolish Hamas’s infrastructure and caches of weapons. These aims, in turn, will likely require at least a temporary occupation of all or part of Gaza. Hamas is simply too entrenched, in too many places, to be rooted out with bombs and raids alone.

But seizing Gaza will prove very costly to Israel. Israeli forces will need to engage in house-to-house urban combat against an enemy that is well prepared and committed to making invaders pay for each inch. Progress will be slow, and the fighting will be brutal. Israel will need to use overwhelming firepower to make serious gains and achieve its objectives. In the process, it may kill enormous numbers of civilians.

And the battle will not end when Israel has reoccupied the territory. There is no Palestinian entity that Israel trusts to govern Gaza in Hamas’s stead. As a result, a military victory could mean Israel has to administer the territory for the foreseeable future. Israeli officials, in other words, will have to govern an immiserated people who see them as their enemy and who may wage a guerrilla war. The prospect of such resistance makes a new occupation of Gaza rather unpalatable for Israeli planners. The best scenario for Israel might be to hit Hamas hard and significantly strengthen Israel’s border with Gaza but not stay too long.

Not what Hamas wanted
Ben Caspit, Al-Monitor

Israel faces a cruel dilemma as it mulls its next steps in the war forced upon it by the October 7 Hamas onslaught against it.
The order issued by the Israeli military command late on Thursday to an estimated 1.1 million Palestinian residents of northern Gaza to leave their homes and relocate to the south of the enclave, suggests that a decision has been made to move ground troops into the enclave. Such an incursion is fraught with danger given that Hamas may have booby trapped areas where they think Israel will invade and that an incursion risks the lives of hostages — mainly civilians, including children, the elderly and the sick — who were seized in Israel and taken to Gaza by Hamas.

“Hamas' victory is also their tragedy. They are stuck with it now and understand the situation,” an Egyptian source said. A “Pyrrhic victory,” is how the source described Hamas’s impressive trampling of the Gaza-Israel border fence and its fighters’ raids on Israeli military bases and communities that left more than 250 soldiers and some 1000 civilians dead, a crushing blow to Israel’s citizenry and deep humiliation of its vaunted army and intelligence. Nearly 150 have been taken hostages into Gaza as well.

“That's not what they [Hamas] planned,” said a senior Israeli military source. “They would have been happy to end the incident with a few dozen dead on our side and two or three abductees. That would have been optimal. They could then have extorted from Israel the release of hundreds of their [members] in Israeli prisons, perhaps even for the construction of a Gaza seaport, in return for the hostages’ release,” he said. “Now, their main goal is to outrun Israel’s bombs and artillery to stay alive, and I wouldn't bet on their chances of success.”

Hamas isn’t ISIS, despite Netanyahu’s appealing slogan
Zvi Bar’el, Haaretz

The Islamic State was an existential threat to Middle Eastern regimes and Western countries’ domestic security. Many Islamic legal rulings by both Sunni and Shi’ite religious authorities defined ISIS not only as a terrorist organisation, but as one that violates Islamic law – an anti-Islamic organization.

Hamas, despite its religious ideology, is seen by the Arab public as an integral part of the Palestinian national struggle. The Islamic State could only dream of such a status.

Fighting Hamas as if it were the Islamic State is a deceptive slogan, and it certainly isn’t a strategy.
When the Islamic State was ousted from the territories it conquered, residents of those areas had a state to live in and a government that was supposed to be responsible for them in every respect. There wasn’t any question about who would control those territories after ISIS fell.
But it’s delusional right now to think the Palestinian Authority would accept responsibility for running Gaza. And that's not just because Hamas, Islamic Jihad and all the other militant organisations are still present and active, but also because tens of thousands of soldiers and loyalists wouldn’t let the PA set foot in Gaza.
Additionally, the scorched-earth “concept” Israel has adopted makes it impossible for any alternative local leadership to fill the vacuum and take power at the point of Israeli bayonets without a comprehensive diplomatic solution that guarantees independent, unified Palestinian rule over both parts of the Palestinian state. But Israel doesn’t currently have a government that would agree to that and is unlikely to have one in the foreseeable future, either.

IDF not close to ending rocket fire, Hamas not close to collapse
Yonah Jeremy Bob, Jerusalem Post

The drumbeat from every IDF commander is that they are tearing Hamas to pieces and it is losing more control of Gaza day after day. There is only one problem with this narrative. Hamas is still firing rockets – every day – and lots of them.

Not only that, but the terrorist group is firing at the center of the country daily, along with the “expected” more regular strikes at civilians from Gaza.

Moreover, although penetrations into Israel by Hamas terrorists on foot across the Gaza border have become rare as the war goes into the middle of its second week, they have not actually stopped.

How “high quality” can many thousands of targets be if they cannot stop Hamas from firing its rockets? How high quality can thousands of targets ever be?

This was a lesson that the US learned belatedly in Vietnam, when it celebrated how many low-ranking Vietnamese foot soldiers it killed without achieving any strategic breakthrough or influencing the Vietnamese overall perception that they were succeeding in wearing the US down.

There is no question that the IDF will “win” tactical victories against Hamas with its overwhelming qualitative weapons advantages. But it is deeply uncertain how soon – and whether – the IDF can cause Hamas to completely collapse militarily, or to at least end the rocket fire on the Israeli home front.

Rage and unity in Israel’s darkest hour
David Horovitz, Times of Israel

They told us they were coming for us. We watched them prepare.

For years, the Prime Minister, who now correctly declares that Hamas is worse than Islamic State and must be defanged, allowed them to be funded and to build up the means to harm us so terribly. He saw them as some form of counter to the Palestinian Authority, with its corrupt leadership, its delegitimisation of Israel, and its internationally backed demands for statehood — demands that Netanyahu once recognised would need to be carefully negotiated, before he lurched into partnerships with extremists with unsustainable maximalist agendas.

For years, our security establishments failed in what may have been the impossible task of persuading their political masters that Hamas was a profoundly dangerous threat, while at the same time underestimating Hamas themselves.

I want to rage at everything that facilitated this darkest hour — at our own internal failings and, pointlessly, at the fact that we are on the front line against rapacious Islamists who seek to destroy everything the civilised world holds dear.

But I know we need to channel anger and frustration and anything that energises us into vital, constructive paths.

Because Saturday showed us we can take nothing for granted in this pitiless part of the world, allow no delusions about the neighbourhood. And that we must keep our innumerable internal differences in check, and in perspective, to ensure that we are resilient enough to prevail.

Photo: Palestinians flee from northern Gaza to the south after the Israeli army issued an unprecedented evacuation warning to  1.1 million people on Friday (Hatem Moussa /AP)

You might also like
  • Netanyahu pushed Shin Bet head to spread racist misinformation at election
    Eetta Prince-Gibson
  • The Israelis who flew home to vote
    Gideon Cohen
  • Iran conflict hinges on Trump’s nuclear nerve
    Dror Doron
logomark.67a07ee3
We believe in the free flow of information

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, by using our Creative Commons licence

You might also like

    Eisenkot Netanyahu
    AnalysisAustralia

    Could the West be regained by an Eisenkot coalition?

    Dean Sherr 2
    Haredi United Torah Judaism
    Israel Votes 2026AnalysisIsrael

    Haredi party may change sides, enabling Eisenkot to form new government

    Shahar Burla
    bulldozer construction settlements west bank
    ExplainerIsrael

    Australia’s latest sanctions raise the stakes, but stay on track

    Deborah Stone

About the author

TJI Wrap

TJI Wrap

TJI wraps consolidate essential news and analysis from multiple sources into digestable summaries.

More from the author

NewsAustralia

War crimes allegations against Australian IDF soldier

NewsWorld

Wave of attacks on Jewish sites sparks international alarm

AnalysisIsrael

Gaza, Lebanon, Syria, Iran: Israel’s tense security landscape

AnalysisIsrael

Middle East on edge as Iran and Israel inch closer to another war