Published: 20 August 2021
Last updated: 4 March 2024
DEBORAH STONE: This week’s events in Melbourne point to a culture of arrogance in a section of the ultra-Orthodox community that feeds carelessness towards state law
THE VICTORIAN PREMIER Dan Andrews carefully avoided the word “Jewish” during his media conference on Monday, as he lambasted the attendees at an illegal engagement party poised to become a Covid-19 super-spreader.
He was right to do so. Citing an ethnic, religious or gender identity in any public discourse is only appropriate if it is relevant. The fact that the partygoers were all Jewish was neither a cause nor a factor of their callous and criminal behaviour.
But among ourselves, the information that the party was a L’chaim held by two visibly-observant Jewish families was a reason for anxiety, embarrassment and internecine tension.
Victoria had been plunged into a longer and stricter lockdown, at least in part because of 69 people who are culturally and religiously aligned with us and who live close to many of us. Nobody was angrier than other Jews.
The direct effect on our community was dramatic. The event spread Covid-19 into the heart of the shtetl. Two kosher bakeries and the biggest supermarkets used by the Jewish community were soon among the exposure sites. Many who bought a challah or went supermarket shopping before last Shabbat were soon in isolation, awaiting Covid-19 test results.
But the greater agony was in the implications for the Jews in the eyes of our fellow citizens. It was a Shande far di Goyim, a disgrace in front of the Gentiles, a Yiddish phrase which captures the exquisite sensitivity Jews feel about the way we are perceived by the non-Jewish community.
As the week played out, fears of antisemitism stirred up by the identification of this rogue element with other Jews proved largely unfounded. As a case study of the health of the Jewish community’s relationship with the broader community, this week’s unfortunate events have been fundamentally reassuring.


