Published: 18 March 2022
Last updated: 4 March 2024
EETTA PRINCE-GIBSON: Destitute refugees will not destroy the Jewish fibre of Israel. But xenophobic politicians trying to guard the ‘Jewish character’ of the state will do just that
MY GRANDMOTHER WAS a refugee. Alone, with two sets of twins under the age of five, she left Tuchin, Ukraine, for Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada, to escape poverty and oppression. Most of the family she left behind was murdered in the Holocaust. My father, a scholar and a rabbi, left Ludmir, now in Ukraine, for Halifax, Nova Scotia, to try to find a life of freedom as a Jew. From his family, only he and his sister survived.
Jacob fled to Egypt to escape famine. The Israelites left Egypt to be free. Jews have fled from the Inquisition, run from pogroms, tried to escape from the Nazis, and, after the Holocaust, built new homes and lives in other places.
Today, some three million people are fleeing Ukraine. Worldwide, according to the World Migration Report 2022, there are close to 300 million displaced people in the world who are crossing oceans, deserts, and mountains to find safety, freedom, the right to be who they are and to feed their families and themselves.
The Torah commands us to collectively remember that we were once strangers and to bring that memory into the present as a religious and moral obligation to show kindness to those who are fleeing and compassion to those in need.
Some of the leaders of the Jewish state seem to have forgotten that to be Jewish is to remember. Some can only understand population statistics and future election results. While we are instructed to treat the stranger as if they were one of us, these officials can only see demographic threats.
Admirably, the State of Israel has organised to take in as many Jews as possible. Many of these prospective immigrants, like many of those from the former Soviet Union (FSU) who came before, have only a tenuous, if any, connection to Judaism, and they certainly do not meet any religious definition of Judaism.


